Login| Sign Up| Help| Contact|

Patent Searching and Data


Title:
COAXIAL SPINDLE CUTTING SAW
Document Type and Number:
WIPO Patent Application WO/2003/026857
Kind Code:
A2
Abstract:
A novel cutting saw assembly (32) is provided with coaxial spindles (44 and 45) each of which supports a cutting saw blade (14). One of the coaxial spindles or spindle shafts is moveable in an axial direction relative to each other so as to position two or more cutting saw blades accurately spaced apart from each other. The two cutting saw blades are dressed to the same diameter and are moveable close together when in operation so that both saw blades can make complete cuts simultaneously on the same wafer, thus increasing the throughput of the cutting saw by almost 100 percent.

Inventors:
RAZON ELI (US)
Application Number:
PCT/US2002/030219
Publication Date:
April 03, 2003
Filing Date:
September 24, 2002
Export Citation:
Click for automatic bibliography generation   Help
Assignee:
RAZON ELI (US)
International Classes:
B27B5/34; B28D5/02; (IPC1-7): B27B/
Foreign References:
US5907984A1999-06-01
US4688540A1987-08-25
US6354912B12002-03-12
JPH06102023A1994-04-12
US6006739A1999-12-28
US5803797A1998-09-08
US5027517A1991-07-02
US3534789A1970-10-20
Attorney, Agent or Firm:
Sowell, John B. (Ardmore, PA, US)
Download PDF:
Claims:
WHAT IS CLAIMED IS :
1. A coaxial spindle cutting saw for dicing wa fers and singulating substrates, comprising: a spindle housing for mounting on a cutting saw; a coaxial spindle mounted in said spindle housing for movement therewith, said coaxial spindle comprising a center spindle having first mounting means for positioning a first cutting saw blade mounted on said center spindle, said coaxial spindle further comprising an outer hollow spindle mounted on said center spindle for ro tation therewith and for axial movement relative thereto, second mounting means for positioning a sec ond cutting saw blade on said outer hollow spindle, a spindle drive motor coupled to said spin dles for rotating both said center spindle and said outer hollow spindle together at the same rotational speed; and spindle positioning means coupled to one of said spindles for accurately positioning one of said cut ting saw blades relative to the other cutting saw blade.
2. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 1 which further includes a second spindle housing mounted on said same cutting saw; and four spindles in said two spindle housings for mounting four cutting saw blades for simultaneously cutting operations.
3. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 2 wherein said spindle housings are mounted with their spindle axes mounted sidebyside and independently moveable in Y and Z axes.
4. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 2 wherein said spindle housings are mounted end toend in substantially the same axis and independently moveable in Y and Z axes.
5. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 1 wherein said outer hollow spindle further in cludes an air bearing surface between an inner diameter of the outer hollow spindle and an outer diameter of the cen ter spindle.
6. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 5 wherein said outer hollow spindle further in cludes an airbearing surface on the outer diameter of said outer hollow spindle.
7. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 6 wherein said positioning motor means further in cludes a voice coil actuating means mounted on said spindle housing for positioning said outer spindle relative to said center spindle.
8. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 6 wherein said actuating means further includes a moveable actuating arm slideable relative to said spindle housing; and an airbearing coupling mounted on said ac tuating arm for movement of said outer spindle.
9. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 6 wherein said positioning motor means further in cludes a moveable actuating arm mounted on said spindle housing; and coupling means mounted on said actuating arm for movement of said outer spindle.
10. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 1 wherein said spindle drive motor is directly coupled to one of said coaxial spindles.
11. A coaxial spindle cutting saw as set forth in claim 1 wherein said spindle drive motor is mounted in or on said spindle housing.
12. A method of making two saw cuts simultane ously, comprising the steps of: mounting a spindle housing on said cutting saw for Y and Z movement relative to a work station, mounting an outer spindle slideably mounted relative to an inner spindle in said spindle housing to provide a pair of coaxial spindles, providing a spindle drive motor for rotating said inner spindle and said outer spindle together in the same spindle housing, mounting a first cutting saw blade on said inner spindle and a second cutting saw blade on said outer spindle, and positioning one of said saw blades relative to the other saw blade by moving one of said coaxial spin dles relative to the other to position said cutting saw blades juxtaposed each other for simultaneously cutting the same work piece on the workstation.
13. The method as set forth in claim 12 wherein the step of positioning one of said saw blades relative to the other comprises: providing a voice coil actuator on said spindle housing, and positioning said outer spindle on said inner spindle by actuating said voice coil of said voice coil ac tuator.
14. The method as set forth in claim 12 wherein the step of positioning further comprises providing an en coder scale on one of said spindles, and sensing the position of said encoder scale to position the moving spindle.
15. The method as set forth in claim 12 wherein the step of positioning further comprises providing an en coder sensor scale on an actuating arm of said spindle housing and sensing the position of the encoder scale to position the moving spindle.
16. A multipiece hub for dual twin and coaxial spindle cutting saws where the spindles have positioning shoulders for receiving a hub, comprising: a hub portion for mounting on said position ing shoulders, said hub portion having a flat disclike flange portion for receiving a cutting saw blade on a radi ally outer annular surface, an annular recess in said flat flange por tion, a flat annular receiving portion in the bot tom of said annular recess, and lock nut means for fitting in said annular recess below said flat disclike flange portion and for mounting on a spindle, whereby two said hubs on two of said spindles may be mounted with their flat disclike flange portions flush against each other.
17. A multipiece hub as set forth in claim 16 wherein said hub comprises an inner flange portion and an outer flange portion for clamping an annular cutting saw blade there between, said locking means comprises an adapter bushing for fitting into said annular recess, and said lock nut means for holding said inner and said outer flanges together on a spindle.
18. A multipiece hub as set forth in claim 16 wherein said lock nut means comprises a locking nut for fitting into the annular recess and for holding said hub onto one of said spindles.
19. A multipiece hub as set forth in claim 16 wherein said locking means comprises a locking nut adapter for fitting into the annular recess and a locking nut for holding said hub onto one of said spindles.
Description:
COAXIAL SPINDLE CUTTING SAW BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 1. Field of the Invention The present invention relates to high-speed pre- cision cutting saws for dicing semiconductor wafers and/or singulating devices from a substrate or printed circuit board. More particularly, the present invention provides a novel coaxial spindle cutting saw using multiple cutting blades driven by a single spindle drive motor.

2. Description of the Prior Art Heretofore, saws for cutting semiconductor wafers were known. Dicing saws are classified in U. S. Class 125 under several subclasses. Cutting saws for dicing silicon wafers usually employ thin flexible blades made from elec- tro-deposited nickel having a fine powder of diamond parti- cles embedded in the dicing saw blades. Such blades are made as annular rings and/or deposited directly onto a mounting flange or hub-like structure and are known as hub blades. Dicing saw blades can be made in thicknesses from about 1/1000th of an inch to over 10/1000th'of an inch and are employed to remove the thin semiconductor street mate- rial that separates individual die on a wafer. The thin cut minimizes the material removed and maximizes the number of die produced on a given size wafer. Sometimes it is preferred to use two separate passes in cutting the same street on a wafer to reduce chipping and to maximize yields.

Singulation saws are used for cutting and sepa- rating packaged semiconductor devices that are already

mounted on Printed Circuit (PC) boards or other forms of strips and substrates and may employ relatively thick dic- ing saw-type blades. Singulation saw blades are also made in the form of a homogeneous mixture of diamonds held in place by a binding material such as epoxy resins and are referred to as diamond impregnated resinoid saw blades and have been used for dicing semiconductor related materials.

The preferred shape of the relatively thick resinoid saw blades is made in the form of an annular ring and clamped and held by inner and outer flanges of a hub. Such saw blades are known as hubless blades.

Both types of saw blades have been used on cut- ting saws having single or dual spindles. Dual spindle cutting saws are used to increase the yield of devices cut by simultaneously cutting paths or streets on the same wa- fer or device so as to decrease the time for processing a wafer or strip or substrate, etc.

As will be explained in greater detail hereinaf- ter, two forms of dual spindle cutting saws are presently used in the semiconductor industry. Both forms of dual spindle cutting saws used in the prior art employed two identical cutting saw heads that are positioned side-by- side for cutting the same street twice or staggered in the Y direction to permit cutting two different streets in a single pass.

Heretofore, dual spindle and twin spindle cutting saws duplicated the cutting saw heads and gantries but em- ployed the same work station and X axis system to improve efficiency of the cutting saw from about 50 to 75 percent.

Accordingly, it would be desirable to provide a novel cutting saw which eliminates duplication of heads and

gantries yet provides a smaller machine size footprint and provides close to 100 percent greater throughput over a single spindle cutting saw at negligible increase in cost.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION It is a principal object of the present invention to provide a novel coaxial spindle cutting saw for driving multiple cutting saw blades.

It is a principal object of the present invention to provide a single spindle drive motor for a coaxial spin- dle cutting saw having multiple cutting blades.

It is a principal object of the present invention to provide a novel coaxial spindle for a cutting saw having means for programming the distance between saw blades from approximately zero up to around five inches.

It is a principal object of the present invention to provide novel hubs and hub adapters for mounting saw blades substantially abutting each other or spaced apart by a predetermined amount.

It is a principal object of the present invention to provide up to three cutting saw blades on a single coax- ial spindle, thus, maintaining a small machine footprint requirement substantially the same as a single spindle cut- ting saw in a multiple blade cutting saw.

It is a principal object of the present invention to provide a multiple blade cutting saw that increases the output of sawn wafers over prior art single spindle cutting saws by the ratio of the number of blades on the coaxial spindle.

It is a principal object of the present invention to provide a novel single coaxial spindle cutting saw that

can double production of a single blade cutting saw of the prior art type at a cost that is very close to a prior art single spindle cutting saw.

It is a principal object of the present invention to provide a multiple blade cutting saw that has higher throughput at lower cost than prior art cutting saws.

According to these and other objects of the pres- ent invention there is a provided in a dicing saw/singu- lation saw a housing for supporting a single coaxial spin- dle and drive motor. The coaxial spindle is adapted to support up to three hubs each of which provides a cutting saw blade operating at the same rotational speed as the other blades. Further there is provided positioning means mounted on the housing which is adapted to position the blades relative to each other in a parallel array which en- ables the multiple blades to simultaneously cut parallel streets or paths through a wafer or surface mounted (SMT) device in a single pass.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS Figure 1 is an isometric view of a prior art twin wafer dicing saw having two housings, two spindles, and two cutting blades arranged as reflected twin images of each other; Figure 2A is a schematic view in front elevation showing the gantry system for moving the cutting saw blades in Figure 1 in X, Y and Z directions; Figure 2B is a schematic view in front elevation of side-by-side or dual cutting saws showing a different gantry arrangement for achieving X, Y and Z direction mo- tions;

Figure 3 is a schematic view in front elevation of the present invention coaxial spindle cutting saw show- ing a single housing and two cutting saw blades operable simultaneously from a single gantry, Figure 4 is an isometric drawing of a preferred embodiment of the present invention coaxial spindle cutting saw showing schematic the drive motor and positioning mo- tors for the spindles and spindle supports; Figure 5A is a schematic side or front elevation of the present invention coaxial spindle singulation or dicing saw showing two blades mounted on the coaxial spin- dles with the rear saw blade moveable in a Y'direction by a voice coil motor; Figure 5B is an enlarged detail of the cutting saw of Figure 5A showing air bearings and seals with the rear saw blade is moveable in a Y'direction by a voice coil; Figure 6 is a modification of the cutting saw shown in Figures 4 to 5B in front or side elevation showing a moveable front saw blade and linear or voice coil drive motor for positioning the moveable front saw blade; Figure 7 is an enlarged detail of a modified cut- ting saw in front or side elevation showing the front or outboard saw blade moveable in the Y'direction by a voice coil mounted on the spindle housing; Figure 8 is an exploded view in elevation and section of two hub-type saw blades, one of which employs an adapter for mounting on dual or twin-type spindles for achieving a minimum space between cutting saw blades; and

Figure 9 is an elevation view in section of a flange-type hub for clamping an annular ring-type saw blade between two flanges.

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS Refer now to Figure 1 showing an isometric view of a prior art wafer dicing saw 10 having two cutting saw heads 11A and 11B each comprising a housing 12, a drive mo- tor 13 and a cutting saw blade 14. The housing 12 is shown mounted for Y-Z support movement on the Y-Z gantry 15. It will be understand that below the saw blades 15 there will be a workstation supporting a wafer or device to be sawn.

Cutting saw 10 further comprises a monitor 16 mounted on cabinet 17 which includes therein controls (not shown).

The control keyboard 18 is shown mounted on the wafer han- dling system 19 but could have been mounted on cabinet 17.

The wafer handling system 19 is shown having four stations Pl to P4. Pl is the docking station from which new wafers are taken by the robotic arm 21 and transferred to the loading station P2. After being sawn the robotic arm 21 simultaneously transfers a new wafer from Pl to P2 and the sawn wafer from P2 to the cleaning station P3. After cleaning the sawn wafer is transferred to the elevator or loading station P4 which will take it down into the system where the magazines are located.

Refer now to Figure 2A showing a schematic view of the cutting saw 10 described in Figure 1. The numerals in Figure 1 that are similar or identical to the structure in Figure 2 are the same and do not require additional ex- planation. It will be noted that the Y-Z support gantry 15 acts as a slider in the Y direction and supports the hous-

ing 12 which supports the motor 13 which supports the cut- ting blades 14. Thus the motor 13 and blades 14 are move- able vertically in the Z direction on support 15 and are also moveable in the Y direction on the Y support shown as 15Y of cutting saw 10.

Mounted on the cutting saw 10 there is shown a pair of X rails 23 which support an X slider 24 which sup- ports a theta access table 25 which supports the chuck 26 on which the wafer/wafer frame 27 is mounted. Thus it will be understood that blades 14 may be lowered into engagement with the wafer 27 and the wafer moved in the X direction by the control system not shown. The cutting saw 10 described in Figures 1 and 2A is also described in U. S. Patent 5,842, 461 and is known as a twin spindle cutting saw.

Refer now to Figure 2B showing a schematic view in front or side elevation of a dual cutting saw 28 of the type shown and described in U. S. Patent 4,688, 540. The side-by-side cutting heads which comprise housings 12 for supporting the drive motors (not shown) which support the cutting saw blades 14 are moveable in the Z direction on the Y-Z supports 15 which are moveable in the Y direction on the Y rails 31. The housings 12 are further moveable with the Z slider 29 to engage the cutting blades 14 with the wafer 27 or substrate mounted on the chuck 26. It will be understood that the side-by-side arrangement of the cut- ting blades mitigates against simultaneous cutting opera- tion on a wafer 27. Thus the improvement over a single spindle cutting saw is in the area of 40 to 50 percent greater throughput, whereas, the twin cutting saw shown in Figure 2A has an improvement factor over a single spindle cutting saw of 70 to 80 percent depending on the size of

the wafer. The workstation 22 is similar or identical to the workstation described in Figure 2A and employs the same numerals and mode of operation as described hereinbefore.

While the efficiency of the cutting saw 28 shown in Figure 2B is lower than the cutting saw shown in Figures 1 and 2A, it has the advantage that the cutting saw blades 14 are easily accessible to replace blades and one saw blade may be used to cut a V groove partially through a wa- fer or substrate and the second blade can be used to cut completely through on the same cut in the same street which reduces chipping.

Refer now to Figure 3 showing a schematic view in front or side elevation of the present invention coaxial spindle cutting saw. The Z slider 29 is coupled to the housing 12 for supporting the novel spindle/spindle housing 35 and is moveable in the Z direction on Z rails 29Z. The Y slider 33 is moveable on the Y rails 34 for a gross or a major movement of the spindle/spindle housing 35. As will be explained in detail hereinafter, one of the two cutting blades 14 is moveable relative to the other cutting blade in the Y prime (Y') direction. The workstation 22 shown below the cutting blades 14 is moveable on the X rails 23 and is substantially the same as the workstation described in Figure 2 hereinbefore. While simultaneously cutting a wafer 27, it may be possible for one of the two blades 14 to wear more or less than the other cutting blade. In this event the cutting blade with the most wear is arranged to cut in a street previously cut by the other saw blade until the two blades again reach the same diameter. Prior art methods may be employed to occasionally check the diameters

of the blades to employ a correction cut or two until the two blades are the same diameter.

Refer now to Figure 4 showing an isometric draw- ing of a preferred embodiment of the present invention co- axial two-spindle cutting saw 32. The Y-Z support or gan- try 15 is shown having a Y slider 33 mounted for movement on the Y rails 34. A Z slider 29 is shown mounted on Z rails 29Z which are supported by the Y slider 33. There is shown a Y drive 36 for moving the Y slider 33. The Z slider 29 is shown supporting the housing 12 which supports the spindle housing 35 and has a Y prime slider 39 mounted thereon and moved by a Y prime drive 38. The Y prime slider 39 is shown having an actuating arm 41 which will be described in greater detail hereinafter for providing the Y prime movement to the outer moveable shaft 44 of the coax- ial spindle which comprises a center shaft 45.

The workstation 22 comprises an X slider 24 slideably mounted on the X rails 23 and moved by the X drive 42. In this view, the chuck and wafer and wafer frame and the blades are not shown so as to describe the details of the coaxial shaft 43 which will be described in greater detail hereinafter.

Refer now to Figure 5A showing a schematic draw- ing in front or side elevation of the present invention co- axial spindle 44,45 for use in the dicing saws previously shown and described.

Figure 5A shows further details of the cutting saw of the type shown in Figure 4 wherein the rear saw or inbound blade 14 is moveable and positionable by a slider 39. The Y-Z gantry 15 is shown supporting a Z slider 29 on the Z rails 29Z for movement in the vertical direction.

The Z slider 29 supports a spindle housing 12 which sup- ports a Y prime rail 46 on which is mounted a Y prime slider 39. The Y prime slider 39 supports an actuator arm 41 which in turn supports an air bearing coupling 49. It will be understood that the outer shaft 44 is preferably supported on an air bearing for slideable movement on the center shaft 45 and the coupling 47 also includes an air bearing which couples to the outer annular ring on the outer shaft 44. It will be understood that the slider 39 is programmed to move the outer shaft 44 which supports the inner hub 48 which comprises a blade portion 14. Thus, it will be understood that the inner blade 14 can be moved to flush engagement with the outer blade 14 so as to cut a wide street or accurately position so as to cut two adja- cent streets on either side of a semiconductor device.

The hub-type blade 48 is basically a modification of prior art single piece hub-type blades and comprises a flat face hub portion 49, a lock nut portion 51. The adap- ter portion 52 permits the lock nut 51 to be flush mounted in against the flat face hub portion 49 so that the hub- type blades can be positioned flush to each other.

Refer now to Figure 5B showing an enlarged draw- ing in side or front elevation of the present invention co- axial dual spindle cutting saw showing two hub-type blades mounted on the coaxial spindles or shafts 44 and 45 with the rear or inboard saw blade 14 moveable by a voice coil assembly 57. There is shown a spindle housing 35 which is moveable in the Y direction and supports the frame of the voice coil assembly 57 which supports therein the electri- cal actuating coils 58. The coils 58 drive the outer move- able shaft 44 which supports the permanent magnets 59 in

the flux field of the actuating coils 58. Shown schemati- cally at 53 is a spine or keyed system which allows linear motion but not relative rotational motion to the center shaft 45. It will be understood that regardless of the type of key or spine that is used, the outer moveable shaft 44 is preferably supported on an air bearing especially for high speed. However, the outer moveable shaft 44 could be supported on conventional bearings especially for low speed or singulation. Further, there is provided a water seal 54 and a water seal 55 to prevent cooling water from entering the system. A pressurized air chamber 56 may be provided to maintain an air flow at the seal 55 to guarantee that no water enters into the moving system.

It is understood that the voice coil assembly 57 moves in the Y direction with spindle housing 35 and has a Y prime linear movement as a result of the voice coil as- sembly moving the outer shaft 44 relative to the outer blade. Thus, it can be seen that the blade portion 14 of the modified hub 48 is capable of being moved into flush contact with each other. Further, the locking nut 51A on the inner hub is recessed in an annular recess 61 so that the flat flange face 49 is capable of moving into abutting relationship with other saw blade. The modified hub 48 is shown having a larger outer locking nut 51 and an adapter 52. In the preferred embodiment of the present invention the voice coil assembly 57 may be accurately positioned with an encoder 50 or a laser interferometer device RH as is known in the prior art.

Refer now to Figure 6 showing a modification of the cutting saw shown in Figure 5A and having a front saw blade 48 that is moveable by an actuating arm 41 mounted on

a slider 39 on the rear of the spindle housing 12. The nu- merals for the work station and the gantry and Z sliders are the same as those shown in previous drawings and do not require additional explanation. There is shown mounted on the housing 12 a Y prime rail 46 on which is mounted a Y prime slider 39 which supports an actuating arm 41 which supports the air bearing coupling 47. In this embodiment the center shaft 45A is modified to extend completely through the spindle housing 35 and supports the outer saw blade assembly 48 which is moveable relative to the inner saw blade shown mounted on the outer fixed shaft 44A which is rotationally fixed to the shaft 45A. Further, there is shown spindle air bearings at both ends of the spindle housing 35 which supports the outer shaft 44A. Further there is shown a spindle motor 63 which is coupled to drive the outer shaft 44A. As explained hereinbefore, the outer shaft 44A is coupled to the inner shaft 45A by either a spline or a key.

Refer now to Figure 7 showing a voice coil assem- bly 57 mounted on the rear portion of the spindle housing 35. In this embodiment the coils 58 cooperate with the permanent magnets 59 to move the permanent magnets 59 which in turn move the inner shaft 45A axially relative to the outer shaft 44A so that the outer hub 48 moves relative to the inner hub and inner blade 14. There is shown a key 66 which is carried by the outer shaft which engages the inner shaft so as to rotate the shafts 44A and 45 together and still allow a linear or axial movement relative thereto.

This is the fine or Y prime movement of the outer hub 48.

Further, there is shown an encode scale 64 mounted on the inner shaft 45A whose position is determined by the sensor

65 mounted on the voice coil assembly housing 57. The nu- merals in Figure 7 that are the same as those shown in pre- vious drawings are similar in structure and mode of opera- tion and do not require an additional explanation. There is an advantage to having the voice coil assembly at the rear of the spindle housing 35 in that it is remote from the cutting blades where the source of cooling water may enter into the actuating system.

Refer now to Figure 8 showing an exploding view of a preferred embodiment multi-piece hub 48 and a conven- tional hub which is modified to provide a feature to be ex- plained hereinafter. The hub 48 comprises a hub portion with a flat face 49 on which the blade portion 14 is depos- ited as known in the prior art. The hub portion also com- prises a recess 61 which in the leftmost hub permits the adapter 52 to fit flush or recessed into the hub. Flange A is preferably thinner than the recess shown at B. The leftmost locking nut 51A locks onto the center shaft 45A or 45 as the case may be. The rightmost hub is shown having an inner diameter C which seats onto the outer shaft 44 or 44A. Further, the locking nut 51A is shown being thinner at thickness A than the depth of the recess 61 shown at B.

This permits the inner flat faces 49 of the hubs 48 to be positioned flush against each other so that the blade por- tions 14 may absolutely touch. While the purpose of the modified and improved hub is to enhance the ability of the present invention cutting saw to make cuts on adjacent street of small die, the same modified hubs may be used in prior art cutting saws of the type similar to that shown in Figures 1 and 2A.

Refer now to Figure 9 showing an elevation in section of a flange-type hub for clamping an annular ring- type saw blade between two flanges. In this embodiment the outer lock nut 51 screws onto the adapter 52 and holds the outer flange 67 in contact with the inner flange 68 which supports the annular ring-type blade 69. Blades of the type shown in Figure 9 are often referred to as hubless and are so named because the annular blade 69 is not a part of a hub but is supported by a two-piece hub.

Having explained a preferred embodiment an sev- eral modifications of the present invention novel cutting saw using coaxial spindle shafts it will be understood that further modification may be made by including a third spin- dle shaft which is a combination of the two spindles shown hereinbefore. The most important feature of the present invention is that it provides substantially 100 percent greater throughput and output over a single spindle and single blade cutting saw as known in the prior art. The two major dual and twin spindle cutting saws have been ex- plained with reference to Figures 1 and 2B and neither of these saws will provide an improved output over a single spindle greater than about 70 percent.

Further, it will be appreciated that the present invention coaxial spindle cutting saw has only one gantry, one set of rails and one spindle housing so that it com- pletely eliminates the need for an extra Y-Z gantry system, extra spindle housing and drive motor. Stated differently, the present invention can be manufactured for slightly more than a single spindle saw and only has the footprint of a single spindle saw yet produces twice the output of a sin- gle spindle saw.

Further it will now be appreciated that the pres- ent invention coaxial spindle cutting saw housing and as- sembly may be retrofitted into saws of the type shown in Figures 1 to 2B as well as in single spindle saw environ- ments.