Field of the Invention

This invention relates to certain new ester- containing quaternary ammonium salts which are useful as charge control agents in dry electrostatographic toners and developers that also serve as adhesion promoters between toner and receiver sheets and as toner fusing temperature reducers.

Description of the Prior Art

In the art of making and using toner powders, charge control agents are commonly employed to adjust and regulate the triboelectric charging capacity and/or the electrical conductivity characteristics thereof. Many different charge control agents are known which have been incorporated into various binder polymers known for use in toner powders. However, the need for new and improved toner powders that will perform in new and improved copying equipment has resulted in continuing research and development efforts to discover new and improved charge control agents.

Of potential interest are substances which not only serve as toner powder charge control agents, but also function as agents that provide additional results or effects such as promoting adhesion between toner and receiver sheets and as toner fusing temperature reducers. Such multi-functionality offers the potential for achieving cost savings in the manufacture and use of toner powders, developers and copier equipment.

It would, therefore, be desirable to provide new salts that could perform the charge-controlling function well in dry, electrostatographic toners and developers as well as promote the adhesion between toner and receiver sheets and, in addition thereto, serve as toner fusing temperature reducers.

SUBSTITUTESHEET

Sii-mmarv of the Invention

This invention provides new ester-containing quaternary ammonium salts having the structure:

wherein R-j_ is alkyl or aryl, R2 is alkyl or aryl, R3 is alkylene, arylene or arylenedialkylene, R4 is alkyl, aryl or aralkyl, R5 is alkyl or aryl, Rg is alkyl, aryl or aralkyl R7 is alkyl or aryl, X is —(—CH2—^, 20 is an anion and n is an integer from 2 to 6.

The salts of the invention have advantageous utility as charge control agents in dry particulate electrostatographic toner powders. Such toner powders comprise a polymeric matrix phase or polymeric binder which has dispersed therein at least one quaternary ammonium salt having incorporated therein two ester- containing moieties that are bonded through alkylene linking groups to quaternary ammonium nitrogen atoms. When incorporated into toner powders, such quaternary ammonium salts not only function as good charge control agents, but also serve as toner powder fusing temperature depressants and paper adhesion promoters. These salts are preferably dispersed in the polymeric binder matrix phase comprising the core or body portion of a toner particle.

Toner powders containing the novel salts of this invention can also be mixed with a carrier vehicle to form electrostatographic developers.

Toner powders containing these salts incorporated into the polymeric binder thereof can be used for producing developed toned images on a latently imaged photoconductor element, for transfer of the toned image from the photoconductor element to a

receiver sheet and for heat fusion of the toned image on the receiver while employing processes and processing conditions heretofore generally known to the art of electrophotography. Various other advantages, aims, features, purposes, embodiments and the like associated with the present invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art from the present specification taken with the accompanying claims.

Description of the Preferred Embodiments

(A) Definitions

The term "particle size" as used herein, or the term "size", or "sized" as employed herein in reference to the term "particles", means volume weighted diameter as measured by conventional diameter measuring devices, such as a Coulter Multisizer, sold by Coulter, Inc. Mean volume weighted diameter is the sum of the mass of each particle times the diameter of a spherical particle of equal mass and density, divided by total particle mass.

The term "glass transition temperature" or "Tg" as used herein means the temperature at which a polymer changes from a glassy state to a rubbery state. This temperature (Tg) can be measured by differential thermal analysis as disclosed in "Techniques and Methods of Polymer Evaluation", Vol. 1, Marcel Dekker, Inc., N.Y., 1966.

The term "melting temperature" or "Tm" as used herein means the temperature at which a polymer changes from a crystalline state to an amorphous state. This temperature (Tm) can be measured by differential thermal analysis as disclosed in "Techniques and Methods of Polymer Evaluation". The term "adhesion index" as used herein is a measure of toner adhesion to paper after the toner has been fused. The adhesion index test involves adhering a metal block to a toner patch and measuring the energy

required to cause interfacial failure between the toner layer and ^" its contacting substrate by collision of a pendulum with the metal block. The range of adhesion ind«ax is from 0 units (no adhesion of the toner to the substrate) to 100 units (excellent adhesion of the toner to the substrate) .

(B) Ester-Con aininσ Quaternary Ammonitim

Salts This invention is directed to ester- containing quaternary ammonium salts of the formula:

wherein R-^ is alkyl or aryl, R2 is alkyl or aryl, R3 is alkylene, arylene or arylenedialkylene, R4 is alkyl, aryl or aralkyl, R5 is alkyl or aryl, Rg is alkyl, aryl, or aralkyl, R7 is alkyl or aryl, X is 0 is an anion and n is an integer from 2 to 6.

As used herein, the term "alkyl" includes straight and branched chain alkyl groups and cycloalkyl groups.

As used herein, the term "anion" refers to negative ions such as m-nitrobenzenesulfonate, tosylate, tetraphenylborate, dicyanamide, chloride, and the like. As used herein, the term aryl includes phenyl, naphthyl, anthryl, and the like.

As used herein, the term "arylene" includes phenylene, naphthalene, and the like.

As used herein, the term "aralkyl" includes benzyl, naphthylmethyl and the like.

As used herein, the term "alkylene" includes ethylene, propylene, butylene, and the like.

SUBSTITUTESHEET

As used herein, the term "arylenedialkylene" means arylenedialkylene wherein the arylene component of the arylenedialkylene moiety includes phenylene, naphthalene, anthracene and the like and the alkylene component of the arylenedialkylene moiety includes alkylene groups containing from 1 to 14 carbon atoms. Examples of specific arylendialkylenes include: ortho-, meta- or para-phenylenedimethy1ene; ortho-, meta- or para-phenylenediethylene; ortho-, meta-, or para-phenylenedipropylene;

2,3,5,6-tetramethyl-p-phenylenedimethylene; 1,4-bis(1,5-pentylene)phenylene; 2,6-naphthalenedimethylene; 1,8-naphthalenedimethylene; 1,1*-biphenyl-2,2*-dimethylene, and

9,10-anthracenedimethylene.

Alkyl and aryl groups can be unsubstituted or substituted with a variety of substituents such as alkoxy, halo or other groups.

Illustrative examples of ester-containing quaternary ammonium salts useful in the present invention include, for example:

N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N,N' ,N'-tetra- methyl-p-xylylenebisammonium bis(m-nitrobenzene- sulfonate) ;

N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N,N' ,N'- tetramethyl-p-xylylenebisammonium dichloride;

N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N,N' ,N'- tetramethyl-p-xylylenebisammonium bis(tetra¬ phenylborate) ;

N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N,N' ,N ^■ - tetramethyl- ,10-anthracenedimethylenebisammonium bis(m-nitrobenzenesulfonate) ; N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl) ,N,N,N' ,N'- tetramethyl-l,4-butylenebisammonium bis(m- nitrobenzenesulfonate) ;

SUBSTITUTESHEET

N,N'-bis(2-(4-chlorobenzoyloxy)ethyl)- N,N,N' ,N*-tetramethyl-p-xylylenebisammonium bis(m- nitrobenzenesulfonate) ;

N,N ^, -bis(2-acetyloxyethyl)-N N,N ^, ,N*- tetramethyl-p-xylylenebisammonium bis(m-nitro- benzenesulfonate) ;

N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N,N' ,N'- tetramethyl-p-phenylenebisammonium bis(m- nitrobenzenesulfonate) ; N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N'-di ethyl-

N,N'-dibenzyl-p-xylylenebisammonium bis(m-nitrobenzene- sulfonate) ;

N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N'-dimethyl- N,N'-diphenyl-p-xylylenebisammonium bis(m-nitro- benzenesulfonate) ; and

N,N'-bis(3-benzoyloxypropyl)-N,N,N' ,N'- tetramethyl-p-xylylenebisammonium bis(m-nitro- benzenesulfonate) .

A presently preferred salt is an ester- containing quaternary ammonium salt of the invention wherein in the formula set forth above R- _j _ is phenyl, R2 is methyl, R3 is p-phenylenedimethylene, R4 is methyl,

R5 is methyl, Rg is methyl, R7 is phenyl, n is 2 and Z ^~ is m-nitrobenzenesulfonate.

(C) Synthesis

The salts of the present invention can be prepared by any convenient route. One general route is to acylate a N,N-di(loweralkyl)amino lower alkanol with an acid chloride to produce the corresponding N,N- di(loweralkyl)amino alkyl ester which is subsequently quaternized with a reactive aliphatic bishalide or to quaternize a N,N,N' ,N'-tetra(loweralkyl)aromatic diamine with a haloalkyl ester. The quaternary ammonium salt is converted to the desired salt by a metathesis or ion exchange reaction with a reactive alkali metal arylsulfonate or other acid salt.

SUBSTITUTE SHEET

Preferably, the acid chloride is benzoyl chloride and the aminoalkanol is 2-dimethylamino- ethanol. In place of the acid chloride, the corresponding carboxylic acid can be employed. Preferably, the N,N,N' ,N*-tetra(loweralkyl)- aromatic diamine is N,N,N' ,N'-tetramethyl-p- phenylenediamine and the haloalkyl ester is 2- bromoethyl benzoate.

One convenient and presently preferred procedure for preparing the ester precursors is to prepare a basic aqueous solution of the tertiary N,N- di(loweralkyl)amino lower alkanol. To this solution is slowly added a solution of the acid chloride in a water immiscible organic solvent, ethylene chloride being presently preferred. The addition is preferably accompanied by rapid stirring. The mole ratio of N,N- di(loweralkyl)amino lower alkanol to total added acid chloride is preferably about 1:1. The ensuing reaction is exothermic and, after the reaction is complete, stirring is preferably continued for a time period, such as at least about 3.25 hours. ^' The organic layer is then separated, washed with water and dried, preferably over MgSθ4 or the like, and concentrated.

The product is typically an oil which can be purified by distillation.

One convenient and presently preferred procedure for the preparation of the quaternary ammonium salt is to prepare the ester and the bishalide quaternizing agent as solutes in the same highly polar solvent, acetonitrile being one presently particularly preferred example. The mole ratio of ester compound to the quaternizing agent is preferably about 2:1. Such a solution is then heated at reflux for a time in the range of from about 10 minutes to about 1 hour. The reaction mixture is then filtered or concentrated by solvent evaporation to yield on oil or a crystalline solid. The product can be used without further purification for the next step in the synthesis, or the

SUBSTITUTESHEET

product can be purified by recrystallization, for example, from a ketone, such as 2-butanone, or the like, followed by washing and drying.

One convenient and presently preferred procedure for preparation of the quaternary ammonium organic salt from the intermediate bishalide is to dissolve the ion exchange agent in water and add this solution to a second aqueous solution containing the quaternary ammonium salt intermediate. The mole ratio of such salt to such ion exchange agent should be about 1:2. Typically, a precipitate is formed immediately which is in the form of an oil which soon crystallizes. This precipitate is collected and water washed (preferably with distilled or deionized water) . The resulting product can be recrystallized from an alkanol, such as isopropanol, or the like, or a ketone, such as 2-butanone, or the like, if desired. (D) Toners And Toner Preparation The quaternary ammonium salts of the present invention are incorporated into toner particles. For present purposes, toner particles -can be regarded as being preferably comprised on a 100 weight percent basis of:

(a) about 0.5 to about 10 weight percent of at least one quaternary ammonium salt;

(b) about 75 to about 97.5 weight percent of a thermoplastic polymer; and

(c) about 2 to about 15 weight percent of a colorant. The size of the toner particles is believed to be relatively unimportant from the standpoint of the present invention; rather the exact size and size distribution is influenced by the end use application intended. So far as now known, the toner particles can be used in all known electrostatographic copying processes. Typically and illustratively, toner particle sizes range from about 0.5 to about 100 microns, preferably from about 4 to about 35 microns.

SUBSTITUTESHEET

The properties of the thermoplastic polymers employed as _. the toner matrix phase materials with the salts of the present invention can vary widely. Typically, and preferably, amorphous toner polymers having a glass transition temperature in the range of about 50 to about 120°C or blends of substantially amorphous polymers with substantially crystalline polymers having a melting temperature in the range of about 65 to about 200°C are utilized in the present invention. Preferably, such polymers have a number average molecular weight in the range of about 1,000 to about 500,000. The weight average molecular weight can vary, but preferably is in the range of about 2 X 10 ³ to about lO"*-". Typical examples of such polymers include polystyrene, polyacrylates, polyesters, polyamides, polyolefins, polycarbonates, phenol formaldehyde condensates, alkyd resins, polyvinylidene chlorides, epoxy resins, various copolymers of the monomers used to make these polymers, such as polyesteramides, acrylonitrile copolymers with monomers, such as styrene, acrylics, and the like.

Preferably, the thermoplastic polymers used with the salts of this invention are substantially amorphous. However, as indicated above, mixtures of polymers can be employed, if desired, such as mixtures of substantially amorphous polymers with substantially crystalline polymers.

Presently preferred polymers for use in toner powders are styrene/n-butyl acrylate copolymers. In general, preferred styrene/n-butyl acrylate copolymers have a glass transition temperature (Tg) in the range of about 50 to about 100°C.

An optional but preferred starting material for inclusion in such a blend is a colorant (pigment or dye) . Suitable dyes and pigments are disclosed, for example, in U.S. Reissue Patent No. 31,072, and in U.S. Patent Nos. 4,140,644; 4,416,965; 4,414,152; and 2,229,513. One particularly useful colorant for the

SUBSTITUTESHEET

toners to be used in black and white electrophotographic copying machines is carbon black. When employed, colorants are generally employed in quantities in the range of about 1 to about 30 weight percent on a total toner powder weight basis, and preferably in the range of about 2 to about 15 weight percent.

Toner compositions, if desired, can also contain other additives of the types which have been heretofore employed in toner powders, including leveling agents, surfactants, stabilizers, and the like. The total quantity of such additives can vary. A present preference is to employ not more than about 10 weight percent of such additives on a total toner powder composition weight basis.

Various procedures are known to the art for incorporating additives, such as the ester-containing ammonium salts of the present invention, colorants, or the like, into a desired polymer or mixture of polymers. For ex.ample, a preformed mechanical blend of particulate polymer particles, quaternary ammonium salts, colorants, etc., can be roll milled or extruded at a temperature sufficient to melt the polymer or mixture of polymers to achieve a uniformly blended composition. Thereafter, the cooled composition can be ground and classified, if desired, to achieve a desired toner powder size and size distribution.

Preferably, prior to melt blending, the toner components, which preferably are preliminarily placed in a particulate form, are blended together mechanically. With a polymer having a Tg in the range of about 50 to about 120°C, or a Tm in the range of 65 to about 200°C, a melt blending temperature in the range of about 90 to about 240°C is suitable using a roll mill or extruder. Melt blending times (that is, the exposure period for melt blending at elevated temperatures) are in the range of about 1 to about 60 minutes. After melt blending and cooling, the

SUBSTITUTESHEET

composition can be stored before being ground. Grinding can be carried out by any convenient procedure. For example, the solid composition can be crushed and then ground using, for example, a fluid energy or jet mill, such as described in U.S. Patent No. 4,089,472. Classification, if employed, can be conventionally accomplished using one or two steps.

In place of melt blending, the polymer can be dissolved in a solvent and the additives dissolved and/or dispersed therein. Thereafter, the resulting solution or dispersion can be spray dried to produce particulate toner powders.

Limited coalescence polymer suspension procedures are particularly useful for producing small sized, uniform toner particles, such as toner particles under about 10 microns in size.

The toner powders used with the salts of the present invention preferably have a fusing temperature latitude in the range of about 275 to about 400°F, although toner powders with higher and lower fusing temperatures can be prepared and used. The toner powders characteristically display excellent paper adhesion characteristics. Typically, the toner powders have a paper adhesion index value in the range of about 30 to about 100, although toner powders with lower such values can be prepared and used. Paper adhesion index values of such toner powders are characteristically higher than those of toner powders prepared with the same polymer and additives but containing a quaternary ammonium salt not of this invention and are comparable to a toner powder prepared with the same polymer and additives but containing no charge control agent.

To be utilized as toners in electrostato¬ graphic developers, toners containing the novel salts of this invention can be mixed with a carrier vehicle. The carrier vehicles which can be used to form such developer compositions can be .selected from a variety of materials. Such materials include carrier core

SUBSTITUTESHEET

particles and core particles overcoated with a thin layer of film-forming resin.

The carrier core materials can comprise conductive, non-conductive, magnetic, or non-magnetic materials. For example, carrier cores can comprise glass beads; crystals of inorganic salts such as aluminum potassium chloride; other salts such as ammonium chloride or sodium nitrate; granular zircon; granular silicon; silicon dioxide; hard resin particles such as poly(methyl methacrylate); metallic materials such as iron, steel, nickel, carborundum, cobalt, oxidized iron; or mixtures or alloys of any of the foregoing. See, for example, U.S. Pat Nos. 3,850,663 and 3,970,571. Especially useful in magnetic brush development schemes are iron particles such as porous iron particles having oxidized surfaces, steel particles, and other "hard" or "soft" ferromagnetic materials such as gamma ferric oxides or ferrites, such as ferrites of barium, strontium, lead, magnesium, or aluminum. See, for example, U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,042,518; 4,478,925; and 4,546,060.

As noted above, the carrier particles can be overcoated with a thin layer of a film-forming resin for the purpose of establishing the correct triboelectric relationship and charge level with the toner employed. Examples of suitable resins are the polymers described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,547,822; 3,632,512; 3,795,618 and 3,898,170 and Belgian Patent No. 797,132. Other useful resins are fluorocarbons such as polytetrafluoroethylene, poly(vinylidene fluoride) , mixtures of these, and copolymers of vinylidene fluoride and tetrafluoroethylene. See, for example, U.S. Pat Nos. 4,545,060; 4,478,925; 4,076,857; and 3,970,571. Such polymeric fluorohydrocarbon carrier coatings can serve a number of known purposes. One such purpose can be to aid the developer to meet the electrostatic force requirements mentioned above by shifting the carrier particles to a position in the

SUBSTITUTESHEET

triboelectric series different from that of the uncoated carrier core material, in order to adjust the degree of triboelectric charging of both the carrier and toner particles. Another purpose can be to reduce the frictional characteristics of the carrier particles in order to improve developer flow properties. Still another purpose can be to reduce the surface hardness of the carrier particles so that they are less likely to break apart during use and less likely to abrade surfaces (e.g., photoconductive element surfaces) that they contact during use. Yet another purpose can be to reduce the tendency of toner material or other developer additives to become undesirably permanently adhered to carrier surfaces during developer use (often referred to as scumming) . A further purpose can be to alter the electrical resistance of the carrier particles.

A typical developer composition containing the above-described toner and a carrier vehicle generally comprises from about 1 to about 20 percent by weight of particulate toner particles ^' and from about 80 to about 99 percent by weight carrier particles. Usually, the carrier particles are larger than the toner particles. Conventional carrier particles have a particle size on the order of from about 20 to about 1200 microns, preferably 30-300 microns.

Alternatively, toners containing salts of the present invention can be used in a single component developer, i.e., with no carrier particles. Toner and developer compositions containing salts of this invention can be used in a variety of ways to develop electrostatic charge patterns or latent images. Such developable charge patterns can be prepared by a number of means and be carried for example, on a light sensitive photoconductive element or a non-light-sensitive dielectric-surface element such as an insulator-coated conductive sheet. One suitable development technique involves cascading the

SUBSTITUTESHEET

developer composition across the electrostatic charge pattern, while another technique involves applying toner particles from a magnetic brush. This latter technique involves the use of a magnetically attractable carrier vehicle in forming the developer composition. After imagewise deposition of the toner particles, the image can be fixed, e.g.,- by heating the toner to cause it to fuse to the substrate carrying the toner. If desired, the unfused image can be transferred to a receiver such as a blank sheet of copy paper and then fused to form a permanent image.

The invention is further illustrated by the following Examples. In these Examples, all boiling and melting points are uncorrected. NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance) spectra were obtained with a Varian Gemini- 200 NMR spectrometer. All elemental analyses were performed by combustion. Unless otherwise indicated, all starting chemicals were commercially obtained.

Examples

Example 1: Preparation of 2-(N.N-Dimethvlamino)ethvl

Benzoate

A solution of 70.29 grams (0.50 mol) of benzoyl chloride in 500 milliters of methylene chloride was added to a solution of 44.57 grams (0.50 mol) of 2- dimethylaminoethanol, 20.0 grams (0.50 mol) of sodium hydroxide and 500 milliters of water over 15 minutes with rapid stirring. Stirring was continued for 3.25 hours after which the organic layer was separated, washed with water, dried over MgSθ4 and concentrated.

Distillation of the residue gave 59.5 grams of product; bp=102-108° C/0.50 mm.

Anal. Calcd. for C ₁₁ H ₁ 5N0 ₂ : C,68.37;H,7.82;N,7.25;

Found: C,66.11;H,7.89;N,7.25. material was sufficiently pure for use in subsequent steps.

SUBSTITUTESHEET

Examole 2: Preparation of N.N'-Bis(2-benzovloxvethvl)-

N.N,N' . '-tetramethvl-p-xvlv enebisammonium

Dichloride

A solution of 38.64 grams (0.20 mol) of 2- (N,N-dimethylamino)ethyl benzoate, prepared as described in Example 1, 17.51 grams (0.10 mol) of α,α'dichloro-p-xylene and 112 milliters of acetonitrile was heated at reflux for 10 minutes. Solid began to precipitate at this time. Acetonitrile (55 milliters) was added and heating was continued for another 5 minutes. The reaction set up to a solid mass and was cooled. The solid was collected with acetonitrile rinse. The solid was washed with ether and dried. The yield of product was 44.0 grams (78.4% of theory); mp=209°C dec.

Anal. Calcd for C ₃ oH3 ₈ Cl2N ₂ θ4: C,64.17;H,6.82;Cl,12.63;N,4.99;

Found: C,63.24;H,6.71;Cl,12.98;N,4.94.

NMR agreed with the proposed structure.

Exam le 3: Preparation of N.N--Bis(2-benzovloxvethvl)- N.N.N' .N'-tetramethvl-p-xvlvlenebisammonium Bis(m-nitrobenzenesulfonate, A solution of 17.11 grams (0.076 mol) of sodium m-nitrobenzenesulfonate in 75 milliters of water was added to a solution of 21.34 grams (0.038 mol) N, '-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)-N,N,N' ,N'-tetramethyl-p- xylylenebisammonium dichloride, prepared as described in Example 2, in 100 milliters of water. An oily precipitate formed which crystallized with stirring. The solid was collected, washed with water and recrystallized from 2-butanone. The yield of product was 21.7 grams (63.81% of theory); mp=180-182°C.

Anal. Calcd. for C ₂ H4 ₆ N 0 ₁₄ S2: C,56.37;H,5.18,-N,6.26;S,7.17;

Found: C,55.24;H,5.15;N,5.98;S,7.87. NMR .agreed with the proposed structure.

SUBSTITUTE SHEET

Examole 4: Toner Powder Preparation (Drv Weiσh Baι=ι-i<=;,

A styrene/n-butyl acrylate copolymer was obtained by limited coalescence polymerization and blended with the additive components identified in the following Table I in the amounts set forth .

ethyl)-N,N,N' ,N'-tetra- methyl-p-xylylenebis- ammonium bis(m-nitro¬ benzenesulfonate) (formulation of Example 3)

N-octadecyl-N,N-di- 0 methylbenzylammonium m- nitrobenzenesulfonate

¹ Parts by Weight

The carbon black was "Regal™ 300". Each blend was roll milled at 150°C for 20 minutes, cooled, crushed and classified to produce a toner powder product having a size of about 12 microns and a size distribution of about 2-30 microns. The charge control agent identified in Table I above as N-octadecyl-N,N- dimethylbenzylammonium m-nitrobenzenesulfonate was utilized for comparative purposes.

Example 5: Fusing And Adhesion Performance

Each of the styrene/n-butyl acrylate toner powder Blends A, B and C was evaluated on a fusing breadboard consisting of a fusing roller coated with 100 mils of red rubber, engaged at constant speed and

SUBSTITUTESHEET

pressure onto a backup roller coated with polytetrafluoroethylene (available commercially as Silverstone ™ from E.I. duPont de Nemours and Co.) Both roller surfaces were coated by hand with a release oil (60,000 centistoke polydimethylsiloxane oil available from Dow Corning Co.). The nip width between the two rollers was 0.215-0.240 inch and the fuser was operated at 12.25 inches/second. The fusing temperature was 350°F. Six longitudinally extending stripes of toner were applied to the wire side of Kodak alkaline DP paper, and the toned papers were run through the fusing breadboard. The transmission density of the toned, fused stripes was between 1.2 and 1.5. The adhesion index was determined for each stripe, and the results for each of the various toner Blends A, B and C are presented in Table II below.

Table II

Average Adhesion Index Blend Charσe Control Aσent (Al) of Toner none 69

B N,N'-bis(2-benzoyloxyethyl)- 68 N,N,N' ,N'-tetramethyl-p-xylyl- bisammonium bis(m-nitrobenzene¬ sulfonate)

C N-octadecyl-N,N-dimethyl- 37 benzylammonium m-nitro- benzenesulfonate

The adhesion index values are the average of 8 measurements and the standard deviations are less than 7 units for the measurements. The toner containing the ester ammonium salt had a significantly higher adhesion index than the toner containing the N-octadecyl-N,N- dimethylbenzylammonium m-nitrobenzenesulfonate charge agent, the comparative charge control agent outside the

SUBSTITUTESHEET

scope of the invention, and had a comparable adhesion index to the toner without any charge control agent.

This invention has been described in detail with particular reference to preferred embodiments thereof, but it will be understood that variations and modifications can be effected within the spirit and scope of the invention.

SUBSTITUTESHEET