INTERNATIONALSEARCHREPORTIntem ial Application No PCT/US00/01086 C. (Continuation) DOCUMENTS CONSIDEREDTOBERELEVANT Category'Citation of document mth indicaLon, where appropnate,oftherelevantpassages RelevanttoclaimNo. P,XWO9947540A(HUMANGENOMESCIENCESINC)1,3,8-16 23September1999(1999-09-23) page135-page136;claims1,7-17 page343 ANCI-CGAP:"National CancerInstitute,1,3 CancerGenomeAnatomyProject(CGAP), TumorGeneIndex http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ncicgap; ow91dO5.x1 Soaresfeta1iversp1eenlNFLS SlHomo sapienscDNAcloneIMAGE:16541853'similar toTR:Q94915Q94915DREG-2PROTEIN.;,mRNA sequence." EMBLDATABASEENTRYAI022747;ACCESSION NO.AI022747,19June1998(1998-06-19), XP002138116 AVANGELDERR.N.ETAL.:"Extentand1-17,20, characterofcircadiangeneexpressionin23 Drosophilamelanogaster:identificationof twentyoscillatingmRNAsintheflyhead" CURRENTBIOLOGY, vol.5,no.12, 1December1995(1995-12-01),pages 1424-1436,XP000864597 cited intheapplication thewholedocument ACASMITHETAL:"Areceptorfortumor1-17,20, necrosisfactordefinesanunusualfamily23 ofcellularandviralproteins" SCIENCE,US,AMERICANASSOCIATIONFORTHE ADVANCEMENTOFSCIENCE,, vol.248,no.248, 25May1990(1990-05-25),pages1019-1022, XP002107350 ISSN:0036-8075 ANOPHARYETAL:"SOLUBLEFORMSOFTUMOR1-17,20, NECROSISFACTORRECEPTORS(TNF-RS).THE23 CDNAFORTHETYPE1TNF-R,CLONEDUSING AMINOACIDSEQUENCEDATAOFITSSOLUBLE FORM,ENCODESBOTHTHECELLSURFACEANDA SOLUBLEFORMOFTHERECEPTOR" EMBOJOURNAL, vol.9,no.10, 1October1990(1990-10-01),pages 3269-3278,XP002025930 ISSN:0261-4189 7 int itional appiication No. INTERNATIONAL SEARCHREPORTPCT/US00/01086 BoxIObservationswherecertainclaimswerefound unsearchable (Continuation ofitem1offirstsheet) ThisinternationalSearchReporthasnotbeenestablishedinrespecto
fcertainclaimsunderArticle17(2)(a)forthefollowingreasons : 1.j Claims Nos.: becausetheyreiatetosubjectmatternotrequiredtobesearchedbythi
sAuthonty,namely : Althoughclaim16isdirectedtoamethodoftreatmentofthehuman/anim
al body,thesearchhasbeencarriedoutandbasedontheallegedeffectsof
the compound/composition. 2.I'llClaims Nos. : 22 becausetheyreiatetopartsoftheInternational Applicationthatdonotcomplywiththeprescribedrequirementstosuc
h anextentthatnomeaningfulInternationalSearchcanbecamedout,spe
cificaily : seeFURTHERINFORMATIONsheetPCT/ISA/210 3.7 Claims Nos.: becausetheyaredependentclaimsandarenotdraftedinaccordancewit
hthesecondandthirdsentencesofRule6.4(a). Box 11Observationswhereunityofinventionislacking(Continuationofi
tem2offirstsheet) ThisInternationalSearchingAuthorityfoundmultipleinventionsin
thisinternationalapplication,asfollows: 1.7 As ail requiredadditionalsearchfeesweretimelypaidbytheapplicant,thi
sInternationalSearchReportcoversail 7 searchableclaims. 2.as aitsearchableclaimscouldbesearchedwithouteffortjustifyingana
dditionalfee,thisAuthoritydidnotinvitepayment ofanyadditionalfee. 3.ars onsomeoftherequiredadditionalsearchfeesweretimelypaidbytheap
plicant,thisInternationalSearchReport covers onlythoseclaimsforwhichfeeswerepaid,specificailyclaimsNos.: 4.Norequiredadditionalsearchfeesweretimelypaidbytheapplicant
.Consequently,thisInternationalSearc.''eu ; restrictedtotheinventionfirstmentionedintheclaims ; st iscoveredbyclaimsNos.: 1-17,20,23partially RemarkonProtest17 The addition31searchfeeswereaccompaniedbytheaDplicant s srotest. J Noprotestaccompamedthepaymentofadditionalsearchfees. . _ FURTHER INFORMATION CONTINUE FROM PCT/tSA/10 1. Claims: 1-17,20,23 (partially) An isolated polypeptide comprising: a) an amino acid sequence of SEQ ID NO: 1, b) a naturally occurring amino acid sequence having at least 90% sequence identity to SEQ ID NO: 1, c) a biologically active fragment of SEQ ID NO: 1, or d) an immunogenic fragment of SEQ ID NO: 1; an isolated polynucleotide encoding said polypeptide; a recombinant polynucleotide comprising a promoter sequence operably linked to said polynucleotide; a cell transformed with said recombinant polynucleotide; a transgenic organism comprising said polynucleotide; a method for producing above mentioned polypeptide; an isolated antibody which specifically binds to said polypeptide; an isolated polynucleotide comprising: a) a polynucleotide sequence of SEQ ID NO: 3, b) a naturally occurring polynucleotide sequence having at least 70% sequence identity to SEQ ID NO: 3, c) a polynucleotide sequence complementary to a), or d) a polynucleotide sequence complemetary to b); an isolated polynucleotide comprising at least 60 contiguous nucleotides of said polynucleotide ; a method for detecting a target polynucleotide in a sample, said target polynucleotide having a sequence of above mentioned polynucleotide; a pharmaceutical composition comprising an effective amount of above mentioned polypetide; a method of treating a disease or condition comprising the administration of said pharmaceutical composition to a patient; methods for screening of a compound comprising inter alia exposing a sample comprising said polypeptide to a compound; a method for screening of a compound for effectiveness in altering expression of a target polynucleotide comprising inter alia exposing a sample comprising said target polynucleotide to a compound.
2. Claims: (partially) Invention II relates to subject-matter as defined above for "invention I", with the exception, that invention II refers to the polypeptide sequence SEQ ID NO: 2 and the respective nucleotide sequence SEQ ID NO: 4.
FURTHER INFORMATION CONTINUED FROM PCTIISA/210 Continuation of Box 1.2 Claims Nos.: 18,19,21,22 Claims 18 and 21 refer to a pharmaceutical composition comprising inter alia an agonist compound or an antagonist compound, respectively, whereby said agonist and antagonist compounds were identified in a certain screening method. Further claims 19 and 22 refer to methods of treating a disease or condition comprising the administration of said pharmaceutical compositions to a patient.
No true technical characterization of such agonist and antagonist compounds is given and no such agonist and antagonist compounds are defined in the application. In consequence, the scope of said claims is ambiguous and vague and their subject-matter is not sufficiently disclosed and supported. No search can be carried out for such purely speculative claims whose wording is a mere recitation of the result to be achieved.
The applicant's attention is drawn to the fact that claims, or parts of claims, relating to inventions in respect of which no international search report has been established need not be the subject of an international preliminary examination (Rule 66.1 (e) PCT). The applicant is advised that the EPO policy when acting as an International Preliminary Examining Authority is normally not to carry out a preliminary examination on matter which has not been searched. This is the case irrespective of whether or not the claims are amended following receipt of the search report or during any Chapter II procedure. INTERNATIONALSEARCHREPORT Interr rlal ApplicationNo Intormation on patent tamily members PCT/US00/01086 Publication Patent family Publication citedin search report date member(s)date WO9940189A12-08-1999AU1049199A 07-06-1999 AU1503099A 05-07-1999 AU2294499A 23-08-1999 EP1029045A 23-08-2000 WO9925825A 27-05-1999 WO9931236A 24-06-1999 WO 9947540A23-09-1999AU3451799A 11-10-1999 AU3072799A 11-10-1999 WO9947538A 23-09-1999