LOW GWP HEAT TRANSFER COMPOSITIONS CONTAINING DIFLUOROMETHANE, A FLUORINATED ETHANE AND 1 ,3,3,3- TETRAFLUOROPROPENE

CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

[0001] The present application claims the benefit of priority under 35 U.S.C. 1 19(e) of U.S. Provisional Application Serial No. 61/801 ,770, filed on March 15, 2013. This application is also a continuation-in-part under 35 U.S.C. 120 of U.S. Application Serial No. 13/530,585, filed on June 22, 2012, which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/507,186, filed on July 13, 2011 . The entire contents of all of the above applications are incorporated herein by reference.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

[0002] This invention relates to compositions, methods and systems having utility in numerous applications, including particularly heat transfer systems such as refrigeration systems. In preferred aspects, the present invention is directed to refrigerant compositions particularly well adapted for use in applications in which the refrigerant 1 ,1 ,1 ,2-tetrafluoroethane (HFC-134a) was previously and frequently used, including particularly for heating and/or cooling applications, and for retrofitting refrigerant and/or air conditioning systems, including systems designed for use with HFC-134a. The preferred use of such compositions is stationary refrigeration and air conditioning equipment.

BACKGROUND

[0003] During the course of the past several years, substantial effort has been devoted to developing more environmentally friendly alternatives to materials which had previously been frequently used for refrigeration and air conditioning purposes. During this time, the main refrigerant used for mobile air conditioning (MAC) systems had been HFC-134a. Although HFC-134a possesses many properties that make it attractive for use in MAC systems, it has a relatively high global warming potential (GWP) of about 1430 (100 years).

[0004] The fluorinated olefin HFO-1234yf has emerged after much research and development effort by the assignee of the present invention as the material of choice to replace HFC-134a in MAC systems. The emergence of HFO-1234yf as the next-generation material of choice for MAC systems is due primarily to its exceptional ability to provide a combination of difficult-to-achieve properties, such as excellent heat transfer characteristics, low toxicity, low flammability, and chemical stability, among other properties. Furthermore, HFO-1234yf is capable of providing this combination of properties with little or no need to be blended with other materials.

[0005] Despite the exceptional and extraordinary success of HFO-1234yf as the next generation refrigerant for many applications, including particularly MAC systems, the present applicants have come to appreciate that circumstances may arise in which HFO-1234yf is not readily available as a result of production capacity limitations, especially in the near term. Accordingly, applicants have come to recognize the need for the development of other materials which might approach the commercial success of HFO-1234yf as the next generation refrigerant.

[0006] Prior to and subsequent to the development of HFO-1234yf, much of the effort directed toward next-generation refrigerants was focused on the development of heat transfer compositions comprised of a blend or mixture of two or more

components. However, these efforts have thus far been generally less than fully successful because of a failure to fully realize one or more of the myriad of properties required for a successful next generation refrigerant.

[0007] The fluorinated olefin 1 ,3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene (HFO-1234ze) has also been identified in an application assigned to the assignee of the present invention as a next generation refrigerant due to its advantageous combination of properties. See, for example, WO 2009/08951 1 . While this application discloses that HFO-1234ze is very attractive as a refrigerant in many applications, it also reveals that it has a substantially lower capacity relative to HFC-134a than does HFO-1234yf in certain air conditioning applications when each is used as the sole refrigerant.

[0008] Blends comprising such fluorinated olefins (e.g. 1234ze or 1234yf) have been suggested for use in a wide variety of applications, including heat transfer compositions. For example, WO 2009/08951 1 , discloses blends comprising as a first component one or more fluorinated olefins according to a particular structure and a second component selected from a list of compounds comprising chloroflurocarbons (CFCs), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) water and CO2. However, the specific combination of components in the particular concentration ranges required by the present invention are not disclosed, and no particular combination of these components is identified in WO 2009/08951 1 as having the advantageous and beneficial properties described herein.

[0009] US Application No. 2010/0044619, which is also assigned to the assignee of the present invention, discloses blends comprising fluorinated olefins for use in connection with heat transfer compositions. This application describes blends comprising as a first component difluoromethane (HFC-32), second component comprising multi-fluorinated olefins having from 2 to 5 carbon atoms, and optionally a third component selected from fluorinated alkanes having to 2 to 3 carbon atoms, CF3I, and combinations of these. According to this application, the second and/or third component of the blend is incorporated for the purpose of acting as an agent for reducing the flammability of the material relative to HFC-32 alone. Once again, however, the specific combination of components in the particular concentration ranges required by the present invention are not disclosed, and no particular combination of these components is identified in US Application No. 2010/0044619 as having the advantageous and beneficial properties described herein.

[0010] Although it is believed that the blends of materials disclosed in the above-noted applications are generally acceptable for use in heat transfer applications under certain circumstances, applicants have found that unexpected yet highly beneficial advantages can be achieved by careful selection of materials within a specific concentration range for forming a heat transfer composition blend which is at once capable of achieving highly desirable heat transfer properties, extraordinarily beneficial environmental properties and exceptionally and unexpectedly nonhazardous

compositions from the standpoint of combustion ignition.

[0011] The burning velocity of a material is one measure that has heretofore been used to assess the hazardousness of the material from a flammability or explosive nature stand point. Thus it has heretofore been considered in many applications that a material having a burning velocity below a value of 10 (measured as described hereinafter), is not only important or essential for many applications, but also that such a material would be considered generally a non-hazardous material from a flammability or explosive nature stand point. Applicants have found that certain compositions exhibit an undesirably high level of hazardousness even when such compositions contain components that would indicate that the material is acceptable for use from a burning velocity stand-point, as discussed more fully hereinafter.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

[0012] Applicants have found that heat transfer compositions having highly desirable heat transfer and environmental properties can be produced which also have an unexpectedly advantageous level of safety or non-hazardousness from the stand point of flammability/combustion impact. More specifically, applicants have found that great but unexpected advantages in this regard can be achieved by the use of compositions comprising HFO-1234ze, HFC-32 and a third component selected from HFC-152a, HFC-134a or combinations of these.

[0013] For embodiments in which the third component comprises HFC-152a, it is important in many applications that the amount of HFC-152a is less than about 20% by weight of the composition, and even more preferably that the amount of HFC-152a is not greater than about 15% by weight of the composition, and also preferably not less than about 5% of the composition. In this regard, applicants have found that

concentrations of HFC-152a of greater than about 20% in such compositions produce compositions with an undesirably high level of hazardousness notwithstanding that such compositions having 20% or greater of HFC-152a would be expected to have a burning velocity of less than about 10. Thus, applicants have surprisingly found that

tremendous advantage can be achieved by requiring such compositions to contain less than about 20% by weight of HFC-152a.

[0014] Applicants have also found that the use of HFC-152a in amounts of about 5% or less have the undesirable effect of increasing the evaporation glide of the blend to such a degree that the use of such blends becomes highly problematic in certain applications, as explained more fully below.

[0015] For embodiments in which the third component comprises HFC-134a, it is important in many applications that the amount of HFC-134a is less than about 6% and greater than about 3% by weight of the composition, and even more preferably that the amount of HFC-134a is not greater than about 5% by weight of the composition, and also preferably not less than about 4% of the composition. In this regard applicants have found that concentrations of HFC-134a of greater than about 6% by weight in such compositions produce compositions with an undesirably high level of global warming potential, while compositions with amounts of less than about 3% by weight have capacity and/or coefficient of performance (COP) that diverges greater than a desired amount relative to pure HFC-134a. In such compositions, it is also preferred that the amount of R-32 in the compositions is from about 7% to about 15% by weight, more preferably from about 8% to about 12% by weight, while the HFO-1234ze(E) is present in the composition in an amount of from about 83% to about 88% by weight, and even more preferably of from about 84% to about 87% by weight. Thus, applicants have surprisingly found that tremendous advantage can be achieved in certain embodiments by requiring such compositions to have each of the components R-32, HFO-1234ze(E) and HFO-134a in the amounts described herein. As used herein unless otherwise indicated, weight percentages for such aspects of the invention are based upon weight percent of R-32, HFO-1234ze and HFC-134a in the composition.

[0016] In preferred aspects, the heat transfer compositions, methods, uses and systems of the present invention comprise or utilize a multi-component mixture comprising: (a) from about 70% to about 90% by weight of HFO-1234ze, preferably transHFO-1234ze (also referred to as HFO-1234ze(E)); (b) from about 5% to about 20% by weight of HFC-32, (c) from greater than about 5% to less than about 20% by weight of HFC-152a; and (d) optionally HFC-134a in an amount of from 0% to less than about 5%. As used herein unless otherwise indicated, weight percentages are based upon weight percent based on the total amount of components (a), (b), (c) and (d) present in the composition.

[0017] In preferred aspects, the heat transfer compositions, methods, uses and systems of the present invention comprise or utilize a multi-component composition comprising: (a) HFO-1234ze, preferably transHFO-1234ze; (b) HFC-32, (c) HFC-152a, and optional components (d), including particularly HFC-134a, with the relative amounts of each component (a) - (d) in the composition being effective to provide said

composition with a GWP (as hereinafter defined) of not greater than 150, and even more preferably not greater than about 100, and an ignition hazard level (as hereinafter defined) of not greater than about 7, even more preferably not greater than about 5, and even more preferably not greater than about 2. In such embodiments it is also generally preferred that the composition has a burning velocity (as hereinafter defined) of not greater than about 10.

[0018] In certain preferred embodiments, the compositions of the present invention have a relative amount of each component (a) - (d) effective to provide said composition with a capacity relative to HFC-134a under MAC conditions (as hereinafter defined) of from about 90% to about 105%, and even more preferably from about 95% to about 101 %, and a COP relative to HFC-134a under MAC condition (as hereinafter defined) for from about 98% to about 102%, more preferably of about 100%.

[0019] In certain preferred embodiments, the compositions of the present invention have a relative amount of each component (a) - (d) effective to provide said composition with an Evaporator Glide (as hereinafter defined) of not greater than about 8, and even more preferably not greater than about 7.

[0020] In certain highly preferred embodiments, the present invention comprises or utilizes a multi-component composition comprising: (a) HFO-1234ze, preferably transHFO-1234ze; (b) HFC-32, (c) HFC-152a, and optionally (d) HFC-134a, with the relative amount of each component (a) - (d) in the composition being effective to provide said composition with: (i) a GWP (as hereinafter defined) of not greater than 150, and even more preferably not greater than about 100; (ii) an ignition hazard level (as hereinafter defined) of not greater than about 7, even more preferably not greater than about 5, and even more preferably not greater than about 2; (iii) a capacity relative to HFC-134a under MAC conditions (as hereinafter defined) of from about 90% to about 105%, and even more preferably from about 95% to about 101 %; (iv) a COP relative to HFC-134a under MAC condition (as hereinafter defined) for from about 98% to about 102%, more preferably of about 100%; and (v) an Evaporator Glide (as hereinafter defined) of not greater than about 8, and even more preferably not greater than about 7.

[0021] The present invention provides also methods and systems which utilize the compositions of the present invention, including methods and systems for heat transfer and for retrofitting existing heat transfer systems. Certain preferred method aspects of the present invention relate to methods of providing cooling in small refrigeration systems. Other method aspects of the present invention provide methods of retrofitting an existing small refrigeration system designed to contain or containing R- 134a refrigerant comprising introducing a composition of the present invention into the system without substantial engineering modification of said existing refrigeration system. According to certain highly preferred aspects of the present invention, the refrigeration system and/or refrigeration methods and/or the refrigerant compositions of the present invention are directed to mobile air conditioning systems, and even more preferably automotive air conditioning systems, and even more preferably air- conditioning systems contained in or used in connection with passenger cars.

[0022] The term HFO-1234ze is used herein generically to refer to 1 ,3,3,3- tetrafluoropropene, independent of whether it is the cis- or trans- form. The terms "cisHFO-1234ze" and "transHFO-1234ze" are used herein to describe the cis- and trans- forms of 1 ,3,3,3-tetrafluoropropene respectively. The term "HFO-1234ze" therefore includes within its scope cisHFO-1234ze, transHFO-1234ze, and all combinations and mixtures of these.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES

[0023] FIG. 1 illustrates a schematic depiction of the experimental setup for the Cube Test.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0024] Small refrigeration systems are important in many applications, as mentioned above. In such systems, one of the refrigerants that have been commonly used is HFC-134a, which has an estimated Global Warming Potential (GWP) of 1430. Applicants have found that the compositions of the present invention satisfy in an exceptional and unexpected way the need for alternatives and/or replacements for refrigerants in such applications, particularly and preferably HFC-134a, that at once have lower GWP values and provide non-flammable, non-toxic fluids that have a close match in cooling capacity and/or efficiency (and preferably both) to HFC-134a in such systems. Applicants have found that the compositions of the present invention satisfy in an exceptional and unexpected way the need for new compositions, especially for small and medium refrigeration applications, having improved performance with respect to environmental impact while at the same time providing other important performance characteristics, such as capacity, efficiency, flammability and toxicity. In preferred embodiments the present compositions provide alternatives and/or replacements for refrigerants currently used in these applications, particularly and preferably HFC-134a, that at once have lower GWP values and provide a refrigerant composition that has a degree of hazardousness, as defined hereinafter, that is substantially lower than the hazardousness of similar compositions but comprising greater than 20% of HFC-152a, while at the same time maintaining a desirably low toxicity, and preferably also having a close match in cooling capacity and/or efficiency to HFC-134a in such systems.

HEAT TRANSFER COMPOSITIONS

[0025] The compositions of the present invention are generally adaptable for use in heat transfer applications, that is, as a heating and/or cooling medium, but are particularly well adapted for use, as mentioned above, in low and medium temperature refrigeration systems, and in automotive AC systems, that have heretofore used HFC- 134a.

[0026] Applicants have found that use of the components of the present invention within the stated ranges is important to achieving the highly advantageous combinations of properties exhibited by the present compositions, particularly in the preferred systems and methods, and that use of these same components but substantially outside of the identified ranges can have a deleterious effect on one or more of the important properties of the compositions of the invention.

[0027] In certain preferred embodiments, the multi-component mixture comprises: (a) from about 5% to about 15% by weight of HFC-32; and (b) from about 70% to about 85% by weight of HFO-1234ze, preferably transHFO-1234ze; and (c) greater than 5% to about 18% by weight of HFC-152a.

[0028] In certain preferred embodiments, the multi-component mixture comprises: (a) from about 5% to about 10% by weight of HFC-32; and (b) from about 70% to about 80% by weight of HFO-1234ze, preferably transHFO-1234ze; and (c) greater than 5% to about 15% by weight of HFC-152a.

[0029] As mentioned above, the preferred compositions exhibit a degree of hazard value of not greater than about 7. As used herein, degree of hazardousness is measured by observing the results of a cube test using the composition in question and applying a value to that test as indicated by the guidelines provided in the following table below:

HAZARD VALUE GUIDELINE TABLE

TEST RESULT HAZARD VALUE RANGE

Substantially complete burning process

and low amount of energy imparted to

some of the balls and substantially no

pressure rise in the cube (some balls rise

an observable small distance and return to 3 - 5

the starting position, and essentially no

movement of the cube observed).

Exemplary of this hazard level is the pure

material R-32, with a value of 4.

Substantially complete burning process

and substantial amount of energy imparted

to most balls and high pressure rise in the

cube but little or no movement of the cube

6 - 7

(most balls rise an observable distance

and do not return to the top of the cube,

but little or no movement of the cube

observed).

High Hazard Conditions - Rapid burning

and substantial energy imparted to all balls

and substantial energy imparted to the

cube (substantially all balls rise from the

cube and do not return to the starting 8 -10

position, and substantial movement of the

cube observed). Exemplary of this hazard

level are the pure materials R-152a and R- 600a, with values of 8 and 10 respectively.

[0030] The cube test is conducted as indicated in the Examples below.

[0031] As mentioned above, applicants have found that the compositions of the present invention are capable of achieving a difficult combination of properties, including particularly: low GWP; excellent capacity relative to HFC-134a; excellent efficiency relative to HFC-134a; an evaporator condition glide of less than about 8; and a hazard value of not greater than 7, and preferably of about 5 or less. By way of non- limiting example, the following Table A illustrates the substantial GWP superiority of certain compositions of the present invention, which are described in parenthesis in terms of weight fraction of each component, in comparison to the GWP of HFC-134a, which has a GWP of 1430.

TABLE A

^* BV = burning velocity

[0032] The refrigerant compositions of the present invention may be incorporated into heat transfer compositions which include not only the refrigerant having the required and optional components for the refrigerant, but which also includes other components for the purpose of enhancing or providing certain functionality to the composition, or in some cases to reduce the cost of the composition. For example, heat transfer compositions according to the present invention, especially those used in vapor compression systems, in addition to components (a) - (d) as mentioned above, also include a lubricant, generally in amounts of from about 30 to about 50 percent by weight of the composition, based on the total of the refrigerant composition and the lubricant, and in some cases potentially in amounts greater than about 50 percent, and in other cases in amounts as low as about 5 percent by weight.

[0033] Commonly used refrigeration lubricants such as Polyol Esters (POEs) and Poly Alkylene Glycols (PAGs), PAG oils, silicone oil, mineral oil, alkyl benzenes (ABs) and poly(alpha-olefins) (PAOs) that are used in refrigeration machinery with hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerants may be used with the refrigerant compositions of the present invention. Commercially available mineral oils include WITCO LP 250® from Witco, ZEROL 300® from Shrieve Chemical, SUNISCO 3GS from Witco, and CALUMET R015 from Calumet. Commercially available alkyl benzene lubricants include ZEROL 150®. Commercially available esters include neopentyl glycol dipelargonate, which is available as EMERY 2917® and HATCOL 2370®. Other useful esters include phosphate esters, dibasic acid esters, and fluoroesters. In some cases, hydrocarbon based oils have sufficient solubility with the refrigerant that is comprised of an iodocarbon, the combination of the iodocarbon and the hydrocarbon oil might be more stable than other types of lubricant. Such combinations may therefore be advantageous. Preferred lubricants include polyalkylene glycols and esters.

Polyalkylene glycols are highly preferred in certain embodiments because they are currently in use in particular applications such as mobile air-conditioning. Of course, different mixtures of different types of lubricants may be used.

HEAT TRANSFER METHODS AND SYSTEMS

[0034] The present methods, systems and compositions are thus adaptable for use in connection with a wide variety of heat transfer systems in general and refrigeration systems in particular, such as air-conditioning (including both stationary and mobile air conditioning systems), refrigeration, heat-pump systems, and the like. In certain preferred embodiments, the compositions of the present invention are used in refrigeration systems originally designed for use with an HFC refrigerant, such as, for example, R-134a. The preferred compositions of the present invention tend to exhibit many of the desirable characteristics of R-134a but have a GWP that is substantially lower than that of R-134a while at the same time having a capacity and/or efficiency (as measured by COP) that is substantially similar to or substantially matches, and preferably is as high as or higher than R-134a. In particular, applicants have recognized that certain preferred embodiments of the present compositions tend to exhibit relatively low global warming potentials ("GWPs"), preferably less than about 150, and more preferably not greater than about 100, while at the same time achieving a hazard value of less than about 7, and even more preferably of not greater than about 5.

[0035] As mentioned above, the present invention achieves exceptional advantages in connection with systems known as low temperature refrigeration systems. As used herein the term "low temperature refrigeration systems" refers to vapor compression refrigeration systems which utilize one or more compressors and a condenser temperature of from about 35°C to about 75°C. In preferred embodiments, the systems have an evaporator temperature of from about 10°C to about -35°C, with an evaporator temperature preferably of about -10°C. Moreover, in preferred

embodiments, the systems have a degree of superheat at evaporator outlet of from about 0°C to about 10°C, with a degree of superheat at evaporator outlet preferably of from about 4°C to about 6°C. Furthermore, in preferred embodiments of such systems, the systems have a degree of superheat in the suction line of from about 1 °C to about 15°C, with a degree of superheat in the suction line preferably of from about 5°C to about 10°C.

[0036] Another preferred system of the present invention is referred to herein as a "automotive AC or MAC systems." Such systems have an evaporator temperature of from about 0°C to about 20°C and a CT of from about 30°C to about 95°C.

Moreover, in preferred embodiments of such systems, the systems have a degree of superheat at evaporator outlet of from about 2°C to about 10°C, with a degree of superheat at evaporator outlet preferably of from about 4°C to about 7°C. Furthermore, in preferred embodiments of such systems, the systems have an increase of

temperature in the suction line of from about 0.5°C to about 5°C, with an increase of temperature in the suction line preferably of from about 1 °C to about 3°C.

[0037] As mentioned above, the present invention also achieves exceptional advantage in connection with systems known as medium temperature refrigeration systems. As used herein the term "medium temperature refrigeration system" refers to vapor compression refrigeration systems which utilize one or more compressors and a condenser temperature of from about 35°C to about 75°C. In preferred embodiments of such systems, the systems have an evaporator temperature of from about 10°C to about -35°C, with an evaporator temperature preferably of about -10°C. Moreover, in preferred embodiments of such systems, the systems have a degree of superheat at evaporator outlet of from about 0°C to about 10°C, with a degree of superheat at evaporator outlet preferably of from about 4°C to about 6°C. Furthermore, in preferred embodiments of such systems, the systems have a degree of superheat in the suction line of from about 1 °C to about 15°C, with a degree of superheat in the suction line preferably of from about 5°C to about 10°C.

EXAMPLES

[0038] The following examples are provided for the purpose of illustrating the present invention but without limiting the scope thereof.

COMPOSITIONS TESTED

[0039] The following compositions within the scope of the present invention are the utilized in the examples which follow:

COMPOSITION Wt% transHFO- DESIGNATION 1234ze Wt% HFC-32 Wt% HFC-152 Wt% 134a

C1 70 10 20 0

C2 60 10 30 0

EXAMPLE 1 : AUTO AC CONDITIONS

[0040] This example illustrates the performance of embodiments A1 - A3 and B1 - B3 of the present invention when used as a replacement for HFC-134a in an auto AC refrigerant systems. The system is one having an evaporator temperature (ET) of about 4°C, with a degree of superheat at the evaporator outlet of about 5°C, and condenser temperature (CT) of about 60°C, with about 5°C subcooling. The system has a degree of superheat at the suction line of about 10°C and an efficiency of about 70%.

[0041] The coefficient of performance (COP) is a universally accepted measure of refrigerant performance, especially useful in representing the relative thermodynamic efficiency of a refrigerant in a specific heating or cooling cycle involving evaporation or condensation of the refrigerant. In refrigeration engineering, this term expresses the ratio of useful refrigeration to the energy applied by the compressor in compressing the vapor. The capacity of a refrigerant represents the amount of cooling or heating it provides and provides some measure of the capability of a compressor to pump quantities of heat for a given volumetric flow rate of refrigerant. In other words, given a specific compressor, a refrigerant with a higher capacity will deliver more cooling or heating power. One means for estimating COP of a refrigerant at specific operating conditions is from the thermodynamic properties of the refrigerant using standard refrigeration cycle analysis techniques (see for example, R.C. Downing, FLUOROCARBON REFRIGERANTS HANDBOOK, Chapter 3, Prentice-Hall, 1988, incorporated herein by reference).

[0042] The properties of each composition and its performance in the exemplary auto AC system is observed to be as follows. These operating parameters are reported in the table below, with the performance based upon HFC-134a having a COP value of 1 .00 and a capacity value of 1 .00:

[0043] The EV full glide is determined by taking the difference between the bubble point and dew point under evaporating conditions of the system.

[0044] The Hazard Value is determined as described above using the Cube Test. The Cube Test is performed pursuant to the procedure described herein.

Specifically, each material being tested is separately released into a transparent cube chamber which has an internal volume of 1 ft ³ . A low power fan is used to mix the components. An electrical spark with enough energy to ignite the test fluids is used. The results of all tests are recorded using a video camera. The cube is filled with the composition being tested so as to ensure a stoichiometric concentration for each refrigerant tested. The fan is used to mix the components. Effort is made to ignite the fluid using the spark generator for 1 min. The test is recorded using an HD camcorder.

[0045] A schematic of the experimental setup for the Cube Test is illustrated in Figure 1 . EXAMPLE 2: AUTO AC CONDITIONS

[0046] This example illustrates compositions within the scope of certain aspects of the present invention, namely compositions B4 - B6 which do not contain HFC-152a, but which do contain HFC-134a using an auto AC system operated as in Example 1 . The results are reported in the following table:

As can be seen from the results reported above, the compositions which do not contain HFC-152a but which contain HFC-134a in accordance with the teachings contained herein show an excellent but unexpected combination of properties, including low GWP, low burning velocity and hazard value, and excellent capacity and COP. The glide of such compositions may be higher than desired for some applications, but is acceptable for many applications.

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 1C: AUTO AC CONDITIONS

[0047] This example illustrates the performance of the compositions outside the scope of the present invention, namely comparison compositions C1 and C2, using an auto AC system operated as in Example 1 . The results are reported in the following table:

As can be seen from the results reported above, the compositions which contain 20 percent by weight or greater of HFC-152a each exhibit a detrimentally and unexpectedly high hazard value, notwithstanding that each composition also has a calculated burning velocity of less than 10.

EXAMPLE 3: MEDIUM TEMPERATURE CONDITIONS

[0048] This example illustrates the performance of embodiments A1 - A3 and B1 - B3 of the present invention when used as a replacement for HFC-134a in a Medium temperature refrigerant system. The system is one having an evaporator temperature (ET) of about -10°C, with a degree of superheat at the evaporator outlet of about 5°C, and condenser temperature (CT) of about 5°C, with about 5°C subcooling. The system has a degree of superheat at the suction line of about 45°C and an efficiency of about 70%.

[0049] The properties of the composition and its performance in the exemplary medium temperature system is observed to be as follows:

B3 R32/R152a/1234ze(E)/R134a(0.07/0.15/0.74/0.04) 127 96% 100% 6.15 4.5

4

[0050] The EV full glide and Hazard Value are each determined as indicated in Example 1 above.

EXAMPLE 4: MEDIUM TEMPERATURE CONDITIONS

[0051] This example illustrates compositions within the scope of certain aspects of the present invention, namely compositions B4 - B6 which do not contain HFC-152a, but which do contain HFC-134a, using an auto medium temperature system operated as in Example 2. The results are reported in the following table:

As can be seen from the results reported above, the compositions which do not contain HFC-152a but which contain HFC-134a in accordance with the teachings contained herein show an excellent but unexpected combination of properties, including low GWP, low burning velocity and hazard value, and excellent capacity and COP. The glide of such compositions may be higher than desired for some applications, but is acceptable for many applications.

COMPARATIVE EXAMPLE 2C: MEDIUM TEMPERATURE CONDITIONS

[0052] This example illustrates the performance of the compositions outside the scope of the present invention, namely compositions C1 and C2, using a medium temperature system operated as in Example 2. The results are reported in the following table:

As can be seen from the results reported above, the compositions which contain 20 percent by weight or greater of HFC-152a each exhibit a detrimentally and unexpectedly high hazard value, notwithstanding that each composition also has a calculated burning velocity of less than 10.