A METHOD FOR PRODUCING LACTIC ACID BY BACTERIAL FERMENTATION

Technical Field

The invention relates to a method of producing lactic acid. In particular, the invention relates to a method for producing lactic acid by means of bacterial fermentation of a substrate.

Background to the Invention

Delactosed whey permeate (DLP) is a by-product of whey processing. DLP contains high concentrations of sodium chloride, phosphates, and 200-400g of lactose per litre of DLP. The lactic acid producing bacteria cannot grow on DLP in batch fermentation, as DLP inhibits the growth of bacteria even at low concentrations. It is an object of the invention to overcome at least one of the above-referenced problems.

Statements of Invention

The Applicant has discovered that Bacillus bacteria, in particular Bacillus coagulans, are capable of growing on substrates such as delactosed whey permeate (DLP) and converting DLP into lactic acid in an efficient and industrially-relevant manner. This is surprising as DLP contains high amounts of salt, sugars, and minerals, which present osmotic and chloride challenges, which are considered to be highly detrimental to bacterial growth. Moreover, lactobacillus bacteria are normally associated with bioconversion of lactose to lactic acid, not bacillus species. The applicant provides data showing that a wild-type Bacillus coagulans strain (MG-2) isolated from soil, and two adapted Bacillus coagulans strains produced from a reference deposited Bacillus coagulans strain, are capable of growing on culture media containing high amounts of DLP (30-50% weight per volume (w/v)) and converting delactosed whey permeate into lactic acid in an efficient and industrially-relevant manner in batch and fed-batch fermenters.

Accordingly, the invention provides a method for producing lactic acid comprising steps of: culturing in a culture medium comprising whey permeate or delactosed whey permeate as a substrate a bioconversion competent bacterial strain capable of converting delactosed whey permeate into lactic acid; and

optionally recovering the lactic acid from the culture medium.

In one embodiment, the substrate is delactosed whey permeate (DLP). In one embodiment, the DLP contains at least 240 g lactose per litre DLP. In one embodiment, the DLP contains at least 15,000 ppm chloride. In one embodiment, the substrate is concentrated whey permeate (CWP). In one embodiment, the CWP contains at least 200 g lactose per litre CWP. In one embodiment, the CWP contains at least 5,000 ppm chloride.

In one embodiment, the bioconversion' competent bacterial strain is a Bacillus strain.

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent bacillus strain is a strain of Bacillus coagulans.

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium containing at least 10% delactosed whey permeate (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium containing at least 20% delactosed whey permeate (v/v). In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium containing at least 30% delactosed whey permeate (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium containing at least 40% delactosed whey permeate (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium containing at least 50% delactosed whey permeate (v/v). In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is a wild-type Bacillus strain (such as MG-2).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent bacillus strain is an adapted Bacillus strain that is adapted to grow in delactosed whey permeate (such as UCD1 and UCD2).

In one embodiment, the adapted bacillus strain is a derivative of a wild-type Bacillus strain.

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with DLP and converting it into lactic acid at least at l OOg lactic acid per litre of DLP with a yield of greater than 85%. Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least lOOg lactic acid per litre of DLP.

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with 10% delactosed whey permeate (v/v) and producing lactic acid typically a yield of at least 90% (w/w). Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least 95% (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with 20% delactosed whey permeate (v/v) and producing lactic acid typically with a yield of at least 90% (w/w). Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least 95% (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with 30% delactosed whey permeate (v/v) and producing lactic acid typically with a yield of at least 90% (w/w). Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least 95% (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with 40% delactosed whey permeate (v/v) and producing lactic acid typically with a yield of at least 90% (w/w). Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least 95% (v/v). In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with 50% delactosed whey permeate (v/v) and producing lactic acid with a yield of at least 90% (w/w). Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least 95% (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with 40% whey permeate (v/v) and producing lactic acid with a 90% yield (w/w). Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least 95%.

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of growing on a test culture medium supplemented with 50% whey permeate (v/v) and producing lactic acid with a 90% yield (w/w). Typically, the process includes a step of recovering lactic acid at a yield of at least 95% (v/v).

In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least lOg lactic acid per litre of fermentation medium containing DLP. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 30g lactic acid per litre of fermentation medium containing DLP. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 50g lactic acid per litre of fermentation medium containing DLP. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 60g lactic acid per litre of fermentation medium containing DLP. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 70g lactic acid per litre fermentation medium containing DLP. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 80g lactic acid per litre fermentation medium containing DLP. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 90g lactic acid per litre of fermentation medium containing DLP. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least lOOg lactic acid per litre fermentation medium containing DLP.

In one embodiment, the culturing step is a fermentation step. In one embodiment, the culturing step is a batch fermentation step. In one embodiment, the culturing step is a fed batch fermentation step.

Various methods of separating lactic acid from fermentation broth are known in the art, including precipitation and filtration followed by ion exchange chromatography. In one embodiment, calcium is added to the fermentation broth to form an insoluble calcium lactate precipitate, which is filtered out of the broth and treated to release the lactic acid.

The culturing step is carried out during a culturing period during which lactose in the substrate is converted to lactic acid. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 100 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 90 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 80 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 70 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 60 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 50 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 40 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 30 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 20 hours. In one embodiment, the culturing period is less than 10 hours. Typically, the process yield (i.e. yield of lactic acid) is at least 70% (w/w).

Typically, the process yield is at least 80% (w/w).

Typically, the process yield is at least 90% (w/w).

Typically, the process yield is at least 95% (w/w).

The invention also provides a method of converting a starting Bacillus strain into an adapted Bacillus strain having a greater tolerance to delactosed whey permeate than the starting strain, the method comprising the steps of:

culturing the starting strain of Bacillus in a first culture medium containing a first concentration of delactosed whey permeate (or concentrated whey permeate);

isolating a first colony of growing bacteria from the first culture medium; culturing the first colony growing bacteria in a second culture medium containing a concentration of delactosed whey permeate (or concentrated whey permeate) that is higher than the first concentration; and

isolating a second colony of growing bacteria from the second culture medium, in which the second colony of growing bacteria comprise an adapted bacillus strain.

In one embodiment, the colony of growing bacteria that are isolated have a colony morphology that matches the colony morphology obtained when the starting strain of bacillus is grown in a culture that is free of delactosed whey permeate (or free of concentrated whey permeate), for example tryptic soy agar. The colony morphology is typically a Bacillus coagulans morphology.

In one embodiment, the culturing step comprises growth on liquid media. In one embodiment, the isolation step comprises growth on solid media. Typically, for each round of culturing and isolation, the liquid media and solid media have the same concentration of delactosed whey permeate. In one embodiment, the culturing step comprises growth in liquid media and a sample of the liquid media is plated on solid media prior to isolation of colonies from the solid media plate. Typically, each round of culturing/isolation includes a step of sampling the liquid culture media after the culturing step for lactic acid concentration. This allows the identification of growing bacteria that are strong lactic acid producers.

In one embodiment, the process comprises at least three rounds of culturing/isolation steps. In one embodiment, the process comprises at least four rounds of culturing/isolation steps. In one embodiment, the process comprises at least five rounds of culturing/isolation steps. In one embodiment, the process comprises at least six rounds of culturing/isolation steps.

In one embodiment, the initial rounds of culturing/isolating comprise a first stepwise increase in DLP concentration, and the subsequent rounds of culturing/isolating comprise further stepwise increases in DLP, where the second stepwise increase in DLP concentration can be equal to or smaller than the previous stepwise increase in DLP concentration. Stepwise increase means that after each round of culturing/isolation, the concentration of DLP in the liquid media is increased in an iterative manner. In one embodiment, the first stepwise increase in DLP concentration is a stepwise increase of 8-12% DLP. In one embodiment, the first stepwise increase in DLP concentration is a stepwise increase of 9-11% DLP. In one embodiment, the first stepwise increase in DLP concentration is a stepwise increase of about 10% DLP. In one embodiment, the second stepwise increase in DLP concentration is a stepwise increase of 3- 12% DLP. In one embodiment, the second stepwise increase in DLP concentration is a stepwise increase of 3-9% DLP. In one embodiment, the second stepwise increase in DLP concentration is a stepwise increase of about 5% DLP.

The invention also provides an adapted Bacillus strain (i.e. adapted Bacillus coagulans strain) produced according to a method of the invention. In one embodiment, the starting Bacillus coagulans strain has a tolerance to DLP of less than 10% (v/v). Tolerance to DLP of X% means that the strain exhibits positive growth on solid media plates containing X% DLP as described below.

In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain has a tolerance to DLP of at least 30%. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain has a tolerance to DLP of at least 40%. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain has a tolerance to DLP of at least 50%.

In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least lOg lactic acid per litre of DLP. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 30g lactic acid per litre of DLP. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 50g lactic acid per litre of DLP. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 60g lactic acid per litre of DLP. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 70g lactic acid per litre of DLP. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 80g lactic acid per litre of DLP. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 90g lactic acid per litre of DLP. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is capable of converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 1 OOg lactic acid per litre of DLP.

In one embodiment, the starting bacillus strain is a Bacillus coagulans. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain is selected from UCD1 and UCD2, or derivatives thereof adapted to grow in higher concentrations of DLP, or convert DLP to lactic acid with greater yield or efficiency. The process of adaption of the invention may be employed to generate derivatives of UCD 1 or UCD2, or MG-2.

The invention also relates to a derivative of MG-2 characterised in that it is adapted to grow in higher concentrations of DLP, or convert DLP to lactic acid with greater yield or efficiency, compared with ML-2. The invention also relates to an adapted strain of the invention in a freeze-dried or frozen format.

Definitions:

"Lactic acid" is an organic compound with the formula CH ₃ CHC0 ₂ H. It is a chiral compound existing in two forms, known as optical isomers, namely D-lactic and L-lactic acid. In the current embodiment, the lactic acid produced with the process and adapted bacteria of the invention is predominantly L-lactic acid (for example >98% v/v). In one embodiment, the term "lactic acid" as used herein should be understood to mean L-lactic acid.

"Whey permeate": Whey is the liquid remaining after milk has been curdled and strained. It is a by-product of the manufacture of cheese and casein. It can exist as sweet whey or acid whey. The whey may be obtained from bovine milk or milk from other mammals such as goats or sheep. Preferably, the milk is bovine milk. Whey permeate is produced by removing protein and other solid components from whey. It is generally produced by treating liquid whey to ultrafiltration or diafiltration. Whey permeate typically contains at least 40 g lactose per litre. Typically, whey permeate contains 1900 to 7600 ppm chloride. The term "whey permeate" also includes concentrated whey permeate (CWP), a product derived from whey permeate evaporation. Typically, concentrated whey permeate contains 200-240 g lactose per litre. An exemplary composition of CWP is provided in Table 3 below. Typically, CWP contains contains at least 5,000, 6,000, 7,000, 8,000, 10,000, 15,000, or 20,000 ppm chloride. In one embodiment, the DLP contains 5,000 to 22,000 ppm chloride. "Delactosed whey permeate" or "DLP" is a by-product of processing of whey permeate to remove lactose that contains at least 200 g lactose per litre of DLP. Lactose removal from whey is quite inefficient, and typically about 50% lactose is removed. After lactose removal by crystallisation, the liquor is concentrated, which means that the DLP has a higher amount of lactose post filtration compared with whey permeate, and higher amounts of salts and minerals, especially chlorides and phosphates. Thus, the term "delactosed" is somewhat of an anomaly. Typically DLP contains at least 200 g or in one embodiment at least 240 g lactose per litre. Typically, DLP contains at least 10,000, 15,000, 20,000, 30,000, 40,000, 50,000, or 60,000 ppm chloride. In one embodiment, the DLP contains 15,000 to 62,000 ppm chloride. In one embodiment, the DLP contains 240-400 g lactose per litre of DLP. An exemplary composition of delactosed whey permeate is provided in Table 1 below.

"Culture medium" (or growth medium) is a liquid or solid preparation designed to support the growth of bacteria. Examples include nutrient broths and agar plates. Examples of solid and liquid culture media are described below. A culture medium containing at least 10% DLP (v/v) means that 10% of the culture medium by volume is made up of DLP.

"Bioconversion-competent strain of bacillus" means a strain of Bacillus bacteria (in particular a strain of Bacillus coagulans) that is capable of growing on a test culture medium containing at least 10% delactosed whey permeate (v/v) typically having at least 240 g lactose per litre DLP and converting DLP into lactic acid at a yield of at least 50%. In one embodiment, the bioconversion competent Bacillus strain is adapted to grow in delactosed whey permeate. Methods for detecting positive growth, and lactic acid production, of Bacillus strains on DLP containing media are described below. In one embodiment, a test bacillus strain is inoculated in liquid medium containing 10% (v/v) DLP and incubated at 54'C for 24 h. Growth can be determined using standard test to detect bacterial growth in culture, including measuring changes in optical density using a spectrophotometer at 600 nm before and after incubation, or by means of a plate count assay. Lactic acid production in the culture medium can be determined using standard methods in the art, for example HPLC.

"Test culture medium" means the solid media described below (Solid Media Preparation).

"Bacillus coagulans" is a lactic acid forming bacterial species within the genus Bacillus. It is a gram positive rod, and generally catalase forming, spore forming, motile and a facultative anaerobe. An example of a Bacillus coagulans is a strain of Bacillus coagulans MG-2 isolated from soil and identified by 16S rDNA sequencing. Other examples of Bacillus coagulans are described in the literature and available from Depository Institutions such as the NCIMB in Scotland (http://www.ncimb.com/) and DSMZ in Germany (https://www.dsmz.de/).

"Wild-type bacillus strain" means a strain of bacillus bacteria that exists in nature e.g. B. coagulans MG-2 isolated from soil (described below).

"Adapted to grow in delactosed whey permeate" means that the adapted strain is produced in an iterative or stepwise culturing process in which the concentration of DLP in the culture medium is increased in each step of the process thereby producing an adapted derivative strain of Bacillus that is capable of growing in a higher concentration of DLP that the non-adapted (starting) strain. The term "tolerance" as applied to the adapted strain means that the strain is adapted to be more tolerant to growth on DLP. An example is a strain of Bacillus coagulans that is unable to grow on solid media containing 10% DLP, but that as a result of the adaption process of the invention is adapted such that it can grow on such media. Bacterial adaption can change the genotype and phenotype of bacteria. The term "growing bacteria" means bacteria that are capable of replicating. "Adapted Bacillus strain" means a strain of Bacillus, typically a strain of Bacillus coagulans, that has been adapted in an adaption process to be more tolerant to DLP (i.e. can grow, or can grow better) than the non-adapted (starting) strain. In one embodiment, the adapted Bacillus strain has been adapted according to a method of the invention. In one embodiment, the starting Bacillus strain is not bioconversion competent, but the adapted strain is bioconversion competent. Examples of adapted strains are described below (UCD1 and UCD2). The starting Bacillus strain can be isolated from nature or obtained from a culture deposit. An example of a starting strain is MG-2 strain described below. Examples of deposited strains of Bacillus coagulans include strains J l 12 (PTA-13253), WCP 10-4 (PTA- 13255), ATCC 7050, ATCC 31284, NCTC 10334.

"Batch fermentation" means a process in which bacteria convert a substrate into a product in a fermenter. It is typically a closed system in which all the nutrients and other additives are added to the system at the start of the process. "Fed batch fermentation" is a similar process in which additives (for example additional nutrients) are added to the fermenter during the process. "Colony of growing bacteria" refers to a colony of Bacillus bacteria grown in a solidified medium containing DLP and which exhibit "positive growth", meaning exhibiting a colony morphology that matches (i.e. similar size and shape) the colony morphology of the same bacteria when grown in a culture medium that is free of DLP, for example Tryptic Soy Agar (TSA). The latter colony morphology may be a typical colony morphology for Bacillus coagulans, which would be known to the skilled person and availably from Bergeys Manual of Archaea and Bacteria (Online ISBN: 97811 18960608).

"Round of culturing/isolation" means a step of culturing bacteria (typically in a liquid medium) and then isolating bacteria (typically in a solid medium).

"Stepwise increase in DLP concentration" in the context of a process for producing an adapted Bacillus strain that involves several rounds of culturing/isolating means that the concentration of DLP in the culture medium is increased after each round of culturing/isolating.

"Tolerance to DLP of X%" means that the strain exhibits positive growth when grown in a test culture medium containing 10% DLP (v/v).

"Yield" in the context of production of lactic acid means the % (w/w) of the lactose in the substrate that is converted into lactic acid. Thus, if the substrate in the fermentation broth (i.e. concentrated whey permeate or DLP) initially contains 200g of lactose and the process produces lOOg of lactic acid and, this is a yield of 50% (w/w).

"Yield" in the context of recovery of lactic acid means the % (w/w) of lactic acid produced that is recovered in a recovery step. Thus, if 20 litres of lactic acid are produced in a fermentation broth, and 18 litres are recovered from the broth, this is a yield 90% (v/v). Method of determining % yield may be determined using HPLC where lactose and lactic acid can be detected by refractive index

Detailed Description of the Invention

Experimental: Solid Media Preparation

The following solid components were mixed in water until completely dissolved and autoclaved at 121°C for 15 min. (the amounts of solid additions were calculated to give the amounts below after the addition of DLP to the media)

Yeast extract 10 g/1

Bis-tris 10 g/1

Agar 1.5 g/1

NH ₄ H ₂ P0 ₄ 2 g/1

(NH ₄ ) ₂ S0 ₄ 3.5 g/1

The DLP was autoclaved at 105°C for 15 min. This temperature was chosen to minimize the amount of lactose loss due to heat and pH dependent Maillard reaction which would be higher at the normal autoclave conditions (121°C for 15mins) used to sterilize microbiological media. It was then mixed with the other sterile media components at the desired concentration.

DLP 10 - 50 % (v/v)

The media was adjusted to pH 6.5 with 6 M NaOH and poured into petri dishes and then allowed to solidify.

Liquid Media Preparation

The following solid components were mixed in water until completely dissolved (the amounts of solid additions were calculated to give the amounts below after the addition of DLP to the media)

Yeast extract 10 g/1

Bis-tris 10 g/1

NH ₄ H ₂ P0 ₄ 2 g/1

(NH ₄ ) ₂ S0 ₄ 3.5 g/1

The DLP was autoclaved at 105°C for 15 min to minimize the amount of lactose loss due to heat and pH dependent Maillard reaction. It was then mixed with the other sterile media components at the desired concentration.

DLP 10 - 50 % (v/v)

The media was adjusted to pH 6.5 with 6 M NaOH

Adaptation process

B. coagulans cannot grow on whey permeate 20% or DLP above 10% volume per volume of growth medium (v/v) 1. The WT Bacillus Coagulans was inoculated on to solid media plates with a range of DLP concentrations (5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30 and 35 % v/v) to determine the growth threshold of the starting strain (wild type (WT)) on DLP.

2. Plates were incubated at 54°C for 16 h, positive growth was determined as colonies matching the time taken to appear on the solid growth media as that of the WT strain when grown on

TSA plates containing 5% DLP under the same incubation conditions.

3. Colonies were determined to be tolerant of 10 % (v/v) DLP. Some small colonies were observed at 15% but they did not match the criteria for positive growth outlined in point 2. No colonies were observed at concentrations of 20% and above DLP.

4. Colonies from plates containing 10% DLP were transferred to liquid media containing 15% DLP, these cultures were incubated without shaking in test tubes at 54°C for 96 hours.

5. Samples were taken from these cultures every 24 h and plated on to solid media containing 15% DLP and incubated as described in point 2. Many colonies were observed from time point 48 to 96 h, but only colonies that met the criteria for positive growth outlined in point two were taken forward for further adaptation by repeating the procedure with the colonies capable of growth at 15 % DLP used as the inoculum for liquid culture with 20% DLP.

6. This process was repeated using 20 to 40 % DLP over a number of months. At this point the 5% incremental increases that had been successful in adapting the strain from 10% DLP to 40% DLP tolerance ceased to deliver the same rate of adaptation. The colonies matching the criteria for positive growth at 40% were stocked and designated as Bacillus Coagulans UCD 1

7. To adapt the strain to higher concentrations of DLP 2% increments were employed with the same sampling and screening methods as described above. These were repeated until colonies matching the criteria for positive growth were isolated on plates containing 50% DLP on solid media. These colonies were stocked and designated Bacillus Coagulans UCD2.

8. Both UCD 1 and UCD 2 were screened for the ability to produce LA from WP and DLP, these adapted strains were capable of LA production using WP (50% v/v) and DLP (50% (v/v)) as the sole source of lactose. The Wild type strain did not grow on WP or DLP at 50% (v/v).

Isolation ofMG-2

Soil samples from UCD were inoculated in liquid medium containing 30% (v/v) DLP and incubated at 54 'C for 24 h. Next, media were inoculated onto solid media and incubated for 24 h at 54'C. Isolates were collected and verified for lactic acid production using HPLC. A sample of media is filtered to remove bacterial cells, the sample is then run on a BioRad HPX-87H hplc column with a flow rate of 0.55 ml min of 0.0014 M H2S04 as the mobile phase. Standard curves of lactic acid and lactose are prepared using analytical standards from sigma aldrich and run in the same manner. Peak area from the media samples for LA and lactose are compared to the standard curve and the yield is determined by comparing the amount of lactose utilised to the amount of lactic acid produced.

One isolate MG-2 was identified as Bacillus coagulans. It produced LA when grown on WP and DLP.

The invention is not limited to the embodiments hereinbefore described which may be varied in construction and detail without departing from the spirit of the invention.

Table 1 Typical Composition of DLP

Calcium Phosphate Chloride Sodium Potassium Magnesium Sulphate Dry Ash % Protein Fat % (DM) Lactose and (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) Matter of DM % DM other

(DM) % organics %

(DM)

Min 827.5 4075 15450 6447.5 14580 735 3405 24 20 5 0.1 60

Average 1655 8150 30900 12895 29160 1470 6810 33 24 8 ^~ .7 68

Max 3310 16300 61800 25790 58320 . 2940 13620 40 28 10 2 75 :

DM =dry matter, PPM = part per million, % w/v = percentage weight per volume

Table 2 Typical composition of Whey permeate (WP)

Calcium Phosphate Chloride Sodium Potassium Magnesium Sulphate Dry Ash % Protein Fat % (DM) Lactose and (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) Matter of DM % DM other

(DM) % organics %

(DM)

Min 175 480 1900 569 - 1348 65 668 6 0.75 2 0.1 80_

Average 349 960 3800 1137 2696 129 1337 10 1.5 4 0.4 86

Max 699 1920 7600 2274 5392 259 2673 12 3 6 1 90

DM =dry matter, PPM = part per million, % w/v = percentage weight per volume

Table 3 Typical composition of concentrated WP (CWP)

Calcium Phosphate Chloride Sodium Potassium Magnesium Sulphate Dry Ash % Protein Fat % (DM) Lactose and

(ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) Matter of DM % DM other

(DM) % organics %

(w/v) (DM)

Min 524 1440 5700 1705.5 4044 194 2005 18 0.75 2 0.1 80 1

Average 1048 2880 11400 3411 8088 388 4010 30 1.5 4 0.4 85.6

Max 2096 5760 22800 6822 16176 776 8020 36 3 6 1 90

DM =dry matter, PPM = part per million, % w/v = percentage weight per volume

Table 4 Strain Tolerance of concentrated WP and DLP

Strain CWP DLP Lactic Acid Lactic Acid

Tolerance (%) Tolerance (%) Yield % cWP Yield % DLP

B. Coagulans Wild Type 20 50 50

B. Coagulans UCD 1 60 ^{" "} 40 90 90

_L B. Coagulans UCD 2 70 50 90 90 ]

B. Coagulans MG2 70 50 90 90