Login| Sign Up| Help| Contact|

Patent Searching and Data


Title:
BLANK FOR FORMING A CONTAINER
Document Type and Number:
WIPO Patent Application WO/2018/060168
Kind Code:
A1
Abstract:
A blank (200) is disclosed having an upper surface (202) and a reverse surface. The upper surface is printed in a conventional manner and includes outer side panels (204a, b) and inner side panels (206a, b). Attachment regions( 208a, b) are provided on the inner side panels (206a, b) of the outer surface (202), and corresponding attachment regions (308a, b) are provided on the outer side panels (304a, b) of the reverse surface. During assembly the respective attachment regions (208a, b, 308a, b) are arranged to face one another and an adhesive is provided therebetween. In the present method, the attachment regions (208a, b) of the upper surface (202) initially have a surface tension in the range from around 34 dynes/cm to 60 dynes/cm before the upper surface (202) is printed. The attachment regions (208a, b) are treated in order to maintain a surface tension in the desired range of 34 dynes/cm to 60 dynes/cm, following printing and before any adhesive is applied. This is achieved by a further, or simultaneous, printing step during which an auxiliary printing medium is applied to the attachment regions (208a, b).

Inventors:
TANAKA KENTA (JP)
LATUSZEK DOMINIC LUKASZ (DE)
CLAUSEN MIKE (DE)
Application Number:
PCT/EP2017/074310
Publication Date:
April 05, 2018
Filing Date:
September 26, 2017
Export Citation:
Click for automatic bibliography generation   Help
Assignee:
JT INT SA (CH)
International Classes:
B31B50/74; B31B100/00
Foreign References:
US20020142904A12002-10-03
Other References:
None
Attorney, Agent or Firm:
GILL JENNINGS & EVERY LLP (GB)
Download PDF:
Claims:
CLAIMS:

1 . Method of printing a blank for forming a container, comprising the steps of: providing a blank having first and second, opposite surfaces, where the first surface has at least one attachment region for attachment to the second surface at a corresponding attachment region during assembly of a container, wherein the first blank surface has a surface tension in a predetermined range, suitable for application of an adhesive; applying a main substance onto at least the first blank surface to obtain at least one printed surface, the main substance selected from the group of an ink, a varnish, a lacquer, or a combination thereof; and treating the attachment region of the first blank surface to maintain a surface tension in the predetermined range by applying a medium to the attachment region or by physically manipulating the attachment region.

2. Method according to claim 1 wherein the predetermined range is between 34 and 60 dynes/cm, most preferably between 36 dynes/cm and 50 dynes/cm.

3. Method according to claim 1 or claim 2, wherein the step of treating the attachment region of the first blank surface involves discharging a gas, a plasma, a high voltage, or a combination thereof.

4. Method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the step of treating the attachment region of the first blank surface involves scorching, grating, abrading or any combination thereof.

5. Method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the step of treating the attachment region of the first blank surface involves applying an auxiliary substance that is selected from the group of an ink, a varnish, a lacquer, or a combination thereof.

6. Method according to claim 5, wherein the auxiliary substance is applied simultaneously with the main substance.

7. Method according to claim 5 or 6, wherein the auxiliary substance is applied over discontinuous areas of the attachment region.

8. Method according to any of claims 5 to 7, wherein the auxiliary substance is applied in a regular distribution on the attachment region.

9. Method according to any of claims 5 to 8, where the auxiliary substance is applied onto between 10% and 97% of the surface of the attachment region, preferably between 15% and 85%, most preferably between 22% and 72%.

10. Method according to any of claims 5 to 9, wherein the auxiliary substance comprises solid particles dispersed throughout a fluid, the largest solid particle size comprised between 1 micrometer and 40 micrometers, preferably between 4 micrometers and 35 micrometers.

1 1 . Method according to any preceding claim, further comprising a step of forming a plurality of score lines or perforations in the attachment regions of the at least one printed surface.

12. A blank for forming a container, comprising: first and second, opposite surfaces, where the first surface has at least one attachment region for attachment to the second surface at a corresponding attachment region during assembly of a container; and a main substance applied on the first surface to obtain a printed surface, the main substance selected from the group of an ink, a varnish, a lacquer, or a combination thereof, wherein before application of the main substance the first blank surface has a surface tension in a predetermined range, suitable for application of an adhesive, and wherein the attachment region of the first blank surface is treated to maintain a surface tension within the predetermined range by applying a medium to the attachment region or by physically manipulating the attachment region, following application of the main substance.

13. A blank for forming a container according to claim 12, wherein the blank is a laminated blank comprising a base board, and a laminate layer, and wherein the laminate layer is the first surface.

14. A container comprising: first and second, opposite surfaces, where the first surface has at least one attachment region for attachment to the second surface at a corresponding attachment region; a main substance applied on the first surface to obtain a printed surface, the main substance selected from the group of an ink, a varnish, a lacquer, or a combination thereof, wherein before application of the main substance the first blank surface has a surface tension in a predetermined range, suitable for application of an adhesive, and wherein the attachment region of the first blank surface is treated to maintain a surface tension within the predetermined range by applying a medium to the attachment region or by physically manipulating the attachment region, following application of the main substance; and an adhesive provided on the treated attachment region, wherein the first and second blank surfaces overlap at the corresponding attachment regions with the adhesive provided therebetween.

15. A method of forming a container comprising the steps of: providing a blank according to claim 13; providing an adhesive to the treated attachment region; folding the blank to form a container such that the first and second blank surfaces overlap at the corresponding attachment regions with the adhesive therebetween; and bonding the corresponding attachment regions together with the adhesive.

Description:
Blank for Forming a Container

The present invention relates to a blank, a container, and respective methods for forming a blank and a container. Typically, containers for smoking articles are formed from blanks made out of paper or card. In order to form a container the blanks are bent and/or folded around a charge of smoking articles. The blanks are then glued together at dedicated overlap regions so as to form the container. The blanks can be laminated, typically by having a base board made out of paper or card, and a laminate layer made out of aluminium foil or PET foil. Figure 1 is a perspective view of a container 2 having a lid 4, a front panel 6 and side panels 8, 10. One side of the blank, including surfaces that will be outward facing in the container, is typically printed before the container formation process is undertaken. During this printing process, inks, varnishes, lacquers, or a combination thereof, are applied to the blanks to create a design and include legally required information, such as health warnings, or manufacturing details. The reverse side of the blank, including surfaces that will be inward facing, is typically (but not necessarily) unprinted. The blanks include overlapping flaps, such as those on the side panels 8, 10, whereby a flap on one surface of the blank is glued to a flap on an opposite surface of the blank to form the container 2.

Containers are typically assembled at high speeds of up to 1 ,000 per minute. At these speeds it has been found that problems can arise in the integrity of the bond between overlapping flaps. In extreme circumstances the bonded flaps may detach, meaning that the container may fall apart. It has been found that laminated blanks are most sensitive to this problem.

Figure 2 is a perspective view of a container 102 in which bonded flaps have become detached. During assembly, a side panel 1 12 on a printed side of the blank is initially glued to a side panel 1 14 on an unprinted side of the blank. The respective side panels 1 12, 1 14 have become detached in the perspective view shown in Figure 2. A fibre tear may occur in a blank made of a fibrous material such as paper or card if the side panels 1 12, 1 14 are separated and the adhesive has maintained its integrity. In these circumstances the blank material would tear and shreds of fibre would be likely to be found on the detached side panels 1 12, 1 14. Notably, no fibre tear or material transfer is evident from the surfaces of the side panels 1 12, 1 14 in the arrangement of Figure 2, which may be indicative of a failure of the adhesive.

One option for circumventing this problem is to use more complex adhesives, which undesirably increase the cost of manufacture. Another option is to reduce the speed of assembly in order to give more time for bonds to adhere, which also increases manufacturing costs.

An object of the present invention is to provide a blank with surfaces that can be bonded more effectively, without otherwise interfering in the assembly process.

According to an aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of printing a blank for forming a container, comprising the steps of: providing a blank having first and second, opposite surfaces, where the first surface has at least one attachment region for attachment to the second surface at a corresponding attachment region during assembly of a container, wherein the first blank surface has a surface tension in a predetermined range, suitable for application of an adhesive; applying a main substance onto at least the first blank surface to obtain at least one printed surface; and treating the attachment region of the first blank surface to maintain a surface tension in the predetermined range.

It has been found that surface tension is an important factor in determining the integrity of a bond. It has also been found that the application of a main substance on the first blank surface may, without counter measures being taken, reduce surface tension in the attachment regions such that it is outside the predetermined range and unsuitable for application of an adhesive. By treating the attachment region it is possible to counteract these undesirable effects and to maintain surface tension in the predetermined range. Thus, treating the attachment region can provide better conditions for an adhesive and decreased risk of detachment, even in high speed manufacturing processes. The surface tension of the attachment region before the application of a main substance and after treatment do not need to be the same; both surface tensions, before and after, need to be comprised within a predetermined range, suitable for application of an adhesive, but their values can differ.

The blank may be provided in a cut or in an uncut form. In an uncut form, the blank is provided as a sheet of material suitable to form the container, such as a paper or card, and, during or after the printing process, the sheet is cut, for example, die cut, to the shape that will be used to form the container. In a cut form, the blank is provided cut from the sheet of material to the shape that will be used to form the container. Alternatively, the blank may be provided cut from the sheet of material to the external shape that will be used to form the blank, and other cuts and crease or score lines will be performed during or after the printing process.

The blank may have a number of different regions each of which exhibit different surface tension values. This may be a result of different design features on the blank and/or the use of different inks or printing materials. The attachment region is active in bonding using an adhesive, and therefore it is believed that the surface tension value in the attachment region is most relevant to the integrity of the eventual bond.

The main substance may be selected from the group of an ink, a varnish, a lacquer or a combination thereof and is applied onto the first blank surface, having the attachment region with a surface tension in the predetermined range. The main substance is preferably not applied in the attachment regions. Nevertheless the application process may affect the surface tension in the attachment regions, in the absence of counter measures. It has been found that treatment of the attachment regions can control the surface tension to enable effective bonding at high speeds.

The predetermined range may be between 34 dynes/cm and 60 dynes/cm, for example, between 36 dynes/cm and 50 dynes/cm. It has been found that a surface tension of less than around 34 dynes/cm yields unsatisfactory bonding at high speeds of manufacture.

The step of treating the attachment region may involve applying a medium to the attachment region or physically manipulating the attachment region to maintain a surface tension in the predetermined range.

The treatment of the attachment region may include a non-treated area for inclusion of printing reference marks to evaluate printing tolerances, such as malalignment of blanks in the different printing steps, or colour deviation. The step of treating the attachment region of the at least one printed surface may involve discharging a gas, a plasma, a high voltage, or a combination thereof onto the attachment region. Alternatively, or in addition, the step of treating the attachment region of the at least one printed surface may involve scorching, grating, or abrading the attachment region, or any combination thereof. The step of treating the attachment region of the first blank surface may involve applying an auxiliary substance. The auxiliary substance may be selected from the group of an ink, a varnish, a lacquer or a combination thereof. Typically the attachment region of the first blank surface is unprinted to improve bonding integrity. Surprisingly it has been found that applying an auxiliary substance can improve bonding integrity and maintain a surface tension in the predetermined range following application of the main substance.

The auxiliary substance may also be applied to other regions of the first blank surface as part of the main substance. Thus, the main substance may comprise the auxiliary substance in certain embodiments. The auxiliary substance may be applied to the attachment region of the first blank surface at the same time as the main substance is applied to the first blank surface. Alternatively the auxiliary substance may be applied before or after application of the main substance. The combined effect of application of the main substance onto the first blank surface and the auxiliary substance onto the attachment region of the first blank surface may result in a surface tension in the attachment region that is within the predetermined range. In one arrangement, the step of applying the main substance onto at least the first blank surface may reduce the surface tension of the attachment region of the first blank surface so that it is outside the predetermined range, and the step of treating the attachment region of the first blank surface may increase the surface tension so that it is within the predetermined range. The auxiliary substance may be applied over discontinuous areas of the attachment region. In one example, the discontinuous areas may be spots or dots, in any convenient pattern, shape or arrangement. The auxiliary substance may also be applied in a regular distribution.

The auxiliary substance may be applied onto between 10% and 97% of the surface of the attachment region, preferably between 15% and 85%, most preferably between 22% and 72%. Surprisingly, it has been found that good bonding results are achieved for less than 100% coverage of the surface area of the attachment region with the auxiliary substance. In one embodiment particularly good bonding results are achieved with 40% coverage. It is anticipated that different optimal values would be achieved with different patterns and types of auxiliary substance. The auxiliary substance may comprise solid particles dispersed throughout a fluid, the largest solid particle size comprised between 1 micrometer and 40 micrometers, for example, between 4 micrometers and 35 micrometers.

The method may comprise forming a plurality of score lines or perforations in the attachment regions of the at least one printed surface. Score lines have been found previously to improve adhesion by increasing absorption of an adhesive in the attachment region during bonding.

According to another aspect of the present invention there is provided a blank for forming a container, comprising: first and second, opposite surfaces, where the first surface has at least one attachment region for attachment to the second surface at a corresponding attachment region during assembly of a container; and a main substance applied on the first blank surface to obtain at least one printed surface, wherein, before application of the main substance, the first blank surface has a surface tension in a predetermined range, suitable for application of an adhesive, and wherein the attachment region of the first blank surface is treated to maintain a surface tension within the predetermined range, following application of the main substance. In the blank, the predetermined range may be between 34 dynes/cm and 60 dynes/cm, for example, between 36 dynes/cm and 50 dynes/cm.

According to yet another aspect of the present invention there is provided a container comprising: first and second, opposite surfaces, where the first surface has at least one attachment region for attachment to the second surface at a corresponding attachment region; a main substance applied on the first surface to obtain a printed surface, wherein before application of the main substance the first blank surface has a surface tension in a

predetermined range, suitable for application of an adhesive, and wherein the attachment region of the first blank surface is treated to maintain a surface tension within the predetermined range, following application of the main substance; and an adhesive provided on the treated attachment region, wherein the first and second blank surfaces overlap at the corresponding attachment regions with the adhesive provided therebetween.

According to yet another aspect of the present invention there is provided a method of forming a container comprising the steps of: providing the blank as defined above; providing an adhesive to the treated attachment region; folding the blank to form a container such that the first and second blank surfaces overlap at the corresponding attachment regions with the adhesive therebetween; and bonding the corresponding attachment regions together with the adhesive. According to yet another aspect of the invention there is provided a method of printing a blank for forming a container, comprising the steps of: providing a blank having first and second, opposite surfaces, where the first surface has at least one attachment region for attachment to the second surface at a corresponding attachment region during assembly of a container;

applying a main substance onto at least the first blank surface to obtain at least one printed surface; and treating the attachment region of the first blank surface to provide a surface tension in the attachment region of between 34 dynes/cm and 60 dynes/cm.

The blank may be a laminated blank comprising a base board made of paper or card, and a laminate layer, preferably aluminium foil or plastic foil, such as, for example, PET, PE, or PP. The laminated blank may additionally comprise a second laminate layer, equal to or different from the first laminate layer, with the base board positioned between the first and second laminate layers.

Apparatus features may be provided as method features and vice-versa.

The present invention will now be described, by way of example, with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:

Figure 1 is a perspective view of a container for smoking articles;

Figure 2 is a perspective view of a container for smoking articles where bonded surfaces have become detached;

Figure 3 is a plan view of a blank for producing a container for smoking articles in an embodiment of the present invention;

Figure 4 is a detailed plan view of an attachment region in an inner side panel on the blank shown in Figure 3;

Figure 5 is a graph showing relative bonding strength for surfaces in a container versus the area of an attachment region coated in an auxiliary substance; and Figure 6 is another perspective view of a container for smoking articles where bonded surfaces have been detached in an experiment. Figure 3 is a plan view of an upper surface 202 of a blank 200. The upper surface 202 of the blank is printed in a conventional manner using an ink, varnish, lacquer, or a combination thereof, to create a design and include legally required information, such as health warnings, or manufacturing details. The reverse surface of the blank 200 is unprinted in this embodiment. However, it is possible that the reverse surface could also be printed, at least partially, so that internal surfaces of the container include designs or information.

The blank 200 includes cut lines (indicated with dotted lines in Figure 3) and fold lines (indicated with solid lines in Figure 3). A hinge line 220 is provided between a lid 222 and the remainder of the pack. The upper surface 202 of the blank 200 includes a front panel 210, a back panel 212 and a bottom panel 214. When the blank 200 is folded and formed around a bundle of smoking articles, the front panel 210, back panel 212 and bottom panel 214 are outward facing. The upper surface 202 of the blank also includes outer side panels 204a, b and inner side panels 206a,b.

A plurality of attachment regions 208a, b, 224a,b, 226a, b, 228a, b are provided on the upper surface 202 of the blank 200 for attachment to the reverse surface of the blank 200 at corresponding attachment regions 308a, b, 324a, b, 326a,b, 328a, b on the reverse surface of the blank 200 (shown in phantom in Figure 3). The attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b are generally unprinted, except for printing reference marks to evaluate printing tolerances, such as malalignment of blanks in the different printing steps, or colour deviation. The entire reverse surface of the blank 200 is generally unprinted. During assembly, the attachment regions 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a,b, 228a,b on the upper surface 202 of the blank 200 are arranged to face the reverse surface of the blank at their corresponding attachment regions 308a, b, 324a, b, 326a,b, 328a, b on the reverse surface. An adhesive is provided at the attachment regions 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a,b, 228a,b of the upper surface 202 of the blank 200 to create a bond between the corresponding attachment regions.

In order to form a container, such as the one represented in figure 1 , the blank 200 is folded in a conventional manner. For example, during folding the outer side panels 204a,b are folded onto the inner side panels 206a, b so that the attachment regions 208a, b are brought against the reverse surface of the outer side panels 204a, b at their corresponding attachment regions 308a, b. Thus, in the formed container the printed upper surface 202 of the outer side panels 204a, b is presented as an exterior surface. It has been found that the properties of the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b on the upper surface 202 are an important factor in determining the integrity of the adhesive bond. One important property appears to be the surface tension of the of the attachment regions 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a, b, 228a, b after the upper surface 202 has been printed. The unprinted blank 200 has a surface tension in the range between 34 dynes/cm and 60 dynes/cm, and most preferably between 36 dynes/cm and 50 dynes/cm. However, experimental results suggest that, following the printing process, the surface tension in the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b can be below 34 dynes/cm, leading to bond integrities that are below the required standard. Even though the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b are unprinted it is currently believed that the process of printing the upper surface 202 can negatively impact surface tension values in the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a,b, 226a, b, 228a, b, leading to poor bonding in formed containers, in the absence of counter measures.

In the present method, the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b 208a, b of the upper surface 202 are treated in order to ensure that, following the printing process, their surface tension is in the range of 34 dynes/cm to 60 dynes/cm, before any adhesive is applied. This is achieved by a further printing step (which may be simultaneous) during which an auxiliary printing medium is applied to the attachment regions 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a, b, 228a,b. In alternative techniques, the attachment regions 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a,b, 228a, b may be treated by application of a gas, a plasma or a current, or by scorching, grating, or abrading. It is believed that these techniques (or any combination thereof) may be deployed in order to yield a surface tension in the desired range, above around 34 dynes/cm and below around 60 dynes/cm. In case printing reference marks are provided in any of the attachment regions, the areas reserved to them are left untreated.

The auxiliary printing medium is an ink, varnish, lacquer, or a combination thereof, comprising solid particles dispersed throughout a fluid. The largest solid particle size is comprised between 1 micrometer and 40 micrometers, typically between 4 micrometers and 35 micrometers. The largest solid particle size can be measured with a grindometer. The auxiliary printing medium may comprise one of the inks, varnishes or lacquers used for printing other regions of the upper surface 202. The auxiliary printing medium is applied in a pattern on the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b. Figure 4 is a plan view of one of the attachment regions 208a, although it will be appreciated that the other attachment regions may be treated in a similar way. In this embodiment the attachment region 208a is printed with the auxiliary printing material in a pattern of regularly spaced spots 230. The size, spacing and pattern produced by the spots 230 may be varied to achieve different results. In some embodiments individual spots 230 may be invisible to the naked eye due to their small size. In alternative arrangements the auxiliary medium may be printed with lines, swirls, dots or any combination of these to achieve a desired pattern.

The size and density of spots 230 is controlled in order to provide a preselected surface area coverage of auxiliary material in the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a,b, 228a, b. Experimental results suggest that the best bond integrities can be achieved with auxiliary material surface area coverage in the range of 1 0% to 97%, preferably 1 5% to 85%, and most preferably 22% to 72%.

A number of test blanks have been analysed to determine relative bonding strength for different surface area coverage of auxiliary material, and the results are set out in the table below.

The table records F max and F bre ak at four different values for the percentage of the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a,b covered in the auxiliary material. F max is the measured force at which the adhesive fails, and therefore F max is considered to be a measure of the strength of the bond between respective attachment regions 208a, b, 308a, b. F bre ak is the measured force at which tearing occurs between respective attachment regions 208a, b, 308a, b. AF is the change in bonding strength, relative to 0% coverage of surface area with the auxiliary material, and expressed as a percentage. AF is calculated according to the following formula:

max,0% "max,X%

where F max, o% is the bonding strength with 0% surface area coverage with the auxiliary material and F max, x% is bonding strength with X% coverage with the auxiliary material. Figure 5 is a graph showing AF versus the surface area of an attachment region 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a,b coated in an auxiliary substance. The graph includes a third order polynomial trend line. It can be appreciated that the best results are achieved for less than 100% coverage. This is achieved with an even distribution of spots 210 across the relevant attachment region 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a,b, 228a,b. The table below indicates the surface area coverage that is required to provide >20%, >30% and >40% improvements in bonding strength relative to 0% coverage with the auxiliary material in the attachment region 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a,b, 228a,b.

The attachment regions may be perforated or scored before or after the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b are treated by printing with the auxiliary material. This may improve water absorption in the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a,b, 226a, b, 228a, b which may improve the action of the adhesive.

During assembly an adhesive is applied to the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a,b on the upper surface 202. The attachment regions 208a,b, 224a,b, 226a,b, 228a,b are then brought against the reverse surface of the panels of the lid 222 and the outer side panels 204a, b at their corresponding attachment regions 308a,b, 324a, b, 326a, b, 328a, b and pressed together so that the panels can be bonded. The adhesive is generally applied across the full area of the relevant attachment regions.

The surface tension of the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a,b that have been treated with the auxiliary material can be measured according to standard techniques. One technique involves the use of test inks. According to this technique, a test ink is selected with a characteristic surface tension value, which has been manufactured according to DIN Draft 53364 or ISO 8296. In this technique the test ink is applied to the surface of the relevant attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b with a brush or a pen filled in with the test ink. Alternatively, a drop of the test ink may be dropped at the relevant attachment regions 208a, b, 224a,b, 226a, b, 228a,b. The liquid in the test ink will either form a continuous film on the surface or else it will pull back into small droplets. If the test ink remains as a film for two seconds, then it is determined that the substrate has a surface tension which is at least that of the characteristic surface tension of the test ink. Should the test ink reticulate or draw back into droplets in less than two seconds, then it is determined that the surface tension of the substrate is lower than the characteristic surface tension of the test ink. It is recommended to apply the test ink to draw a line with a minimum length of 5mm, preferably of 10mm, that does not traverse printing reference marks, to properly visualise the behaviour of the test ink. The precise surface tension is determined by applying a number of test inks with increasing or decreasing characteristic surface tension values until the surface tension of the substrate can be accurately determined. This technique can provide a value for the surface tension of the attachment regions 208a,b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b following treatment with an accuracy of ±2 dynes/cm.

In case the attachment region is treated by printing a pattern of lines, swirls, dots, or a combination thereof, surface tension may be measured over an area that is larger than the area of any individual element. This is especially true when the individual elements are too small to be distinguished by naked eye. In case the printed pattern consists of parallel lines, surface tension should be measured by drawing a line substantially perpendicular to the printed parallel lines to ensure that printed lines are traversed.

Another technique can be performed with the naked eye to determine the surface tension of the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b following treatment. According to this technique, bonded panels can be manually pulled apart twenty-four hours after they have been bonded together. The exposed attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a,b on the upper surface 202 can then be visually inspected to determine whether there has been any material transfer from the attachment regions 308a,b, 324a, b, 326a, b, 328a, b on the lower surface. A material transfer would be visible where the paper has ripped and shreds of fibre from the attachment regions 308a, b, 324a,b, 326a, b, 328a,b on the lower surface are found on the attachment regions 208a, b, 224a, b, 226a, b, 228a, b on the upper surface 202. Figure 6 is a perspective view of a container 402 for smoking articles where bonded surfaces have been detached in an experiment. In the container 402, an attachment region 408 on a printed inner side panel 406 was initially glued to an attachment region 508 of an unprinted outer side panel 504. The inner side panel 406 is manually separated from the outer side panel 504 and shreds of fibre 550 are evident on the attachment region 408 of the printed inner side panel 406, indicating that a material transfer has occurred. It has been determined that a material transfer is found where the surface tension in the attachment region 408 following treatment is between 34 dynes/cm and 60 dynes/cm. Therefore, a simple visual inspection can reveal whether the surface tension of the attachment regions 208a,b is above around 34 dynes/cm.

It has been determined that high quality bond provides a bonding strength that is higher than the breaking resistance of the blank material. Therefore, when a high quality bond is achieved separating the adhered surfaces results in material tear that is apparent on the surface of the attachment regions. A material tear is especially evident when the blank from which the container is formed is made from a fibre-based material, such as coated or uncoated cardboard. In the latter case, fibre remains will be apparent on the surface of the attachment regions if the bonding quality is high. Substantial coverage of the attachment region 408 with fibre remains following separation is a clear naked-eye indication that the surface tension of the attachment region 408 is above 34 dynes/cm. Conversely, if the bonding quality is poor because the attachment region has a surface tension of less than 34 dynes/cm or more than around 60 dynes/cm then no material transfer will be evident following separation.